The 10 Best Car Insurance Companies (2026)

American Family is the best car insurance company for most people. NJM, Erie and USAA are also some of the best-rated companies.

Find the Best Cheap Auto Insurance Quotes in Your Area

On means insured, off means not insured.
It's free, simple and secure.

Top 10 best car insurance companies

ValuePenguin editors award companies a maximum of five stars based on factors such as cost, coverage availability and customer service reviews.

Find the Best Cheap Auto Insurance Quotes in Your Area

On means insured, off means not insured.
It's free, simple and secure.

Best car insurance overall: American Family

Editor's rating
Editor's rating
  • Editor's rating
    ValuePenguin's team scores insurance companies based on independent research, factoring in customer support, cost, coverage and overall shopping experience. American Family's rating is for its auto insurance product only. Home and renters insurance are rated separately.
    4.5/5
  • Full coverage
    Average rate for a typical driver with a clean driving record and good credit. Full methodology.
    $159/mo
American Family has the best car insurance for most drivers because it's cheap, reliable and easy to navigate.

Go with another company if you want to bundle your home and auto insurance with the same company, as American Family's home insurance tends to be expensive, or if you live in one of the where American Family isn't available.

American Family pros & cons
Price
Cheap
Cheap
Customer service
Average
Average
Bundling
Poor
Expensive home insurance

Best regional car insurance company: NJM

Editor's rating
Editor's rating
  • Editor's rating
    ValuePenguin's team scores insurance companies based on independent research, factoring in customer support, cost, coverage and overall shopping experience.
    5/5
  • Full coverage
    Average rate for a typical driver with a clean driving record and good credit. Full methodology.
    $168/mo
NJM is the best regional company because it has cheap quotes and some of the best customer reviews in the industry.

Go with another company if you live outside of Connecticut, Maryland, New Jersey, Ohio or Pennsylvania — the only five states where it sells insurance.

NJM pros & cons
Price
Cheap
Cheap
Customer service
Excellent
Excellent
Availability
Only available in 5 states
Only in 5 states

Best company for cheap insurance: Erie

Editor's rating
Editor's rating
  • Editor's rating
    ValuePenguin's team scores insurance companies based on independent research, factoring in customer support, cost, coverage and overall shopping experience.
    4.5/5
  • Full coverage
    Average rate for a typical driver with a clean driving record and good credit. Full methodology.
    $154/mo
Erie is the best because it has incredibly affordable rates, and you don't have to sacrifice good customer service.

Go with another company if you want to buy a policy online, or you live outside of the where it sells insurance.

Erie pros & cons
Price
Cheapest
Cheapest
Customer service
Excellent
Excellent
Can buy online
No

Best customer service: Amica

Editor's rating
Editor's rating
  • Editor's rating
    ValuePenguin's team scores insurance companies based on independent research, factoring in customer support, cost, coverage and overall shopping experience.
    4/5
  • Full coverage
    Average rate for a typical driver with a clean driving record and good credit. Full methodology.
    $285/mo
Amica is the best because it has great customer reviews and often ranks as a top company in customer surveys.

Go with another company if you're on a tight budget and value cheap rates over great service.
Amica pros & cons
Price
Expensive
Expensive
Customer service
Best
Best
Coverage
More optional add-ons than average
Lots of options

Best car insurance coverage: Shelter

Editor's rating
Editor's rating
  • Editor's rating
    ValuePenguin's team scores insurance companies based on independent research, factoring in customer support, cost, coverage and overall shopping experience
    4.5/5
  • Full coverage
    Average rate for a typical driver with a clean driving record and good credit. Full methodology.
    $192/mo
Shelter is the best because its basic full coverage policy includes protection other companies typically charge extra for.

Go with another company if you want to buy your policy online, have poor credit or live outside of the where it sells insurance.

Shelter pros & cons
Price
Cheap
Cheap
Customer service
Good
Good
Can buy online?
No
No

Best car insurance after an accident: State Farm

Editor's rating
Editor's rating
  • Editor's rating
    ValuePenguin's team scores insurance companies based on independent research, factoring in customer support, cost, coverage and overall shopping experience.
    4.5/5
  • Full coverage after a crash
    Average rate for a typical driver with one at-fault accident on their record and good credit. Full methodology.
    $218/mo
State Farm is the best because it won't raise your rates much after a crash, and its reliable service will come in handy if you're in another accident.

Go with another company if you want to upgrade your coverage with extra protection or have a poor credit score.

State Farm pros & cons
Price
Cheap
Cheap
Customer service
Good
Good
Coverage extras
Fewer than average
Basic

Best company for families with teens: Auto-Owners

Editor's rating
Editor's rating
  • Editor's rating
    ValuePenguin's team scores insurance companies based on independent research, factoring in customer support, cost, coverage and overall shopping experience.
    4.5/5
  • Full coverage
    Average rate for a typical driver with a clean driving record and good credit. Full methodology.
    $171/mo
Auto-Owners is the best because it has affordable rates for teen drivers, and people are mostly happy with their claims experience after a crash.

Go with another company if you want to buy your policy online or prefer to bundle your auto and home insurance, as Auto-Owners tends to have expensive home insurance rates.

Auto-Owners pros & cons
Price
Cheap
Cheap
Customer service
Average
Mediocre
Coverage add-ons
More than average
Many

Best mobile app: Geico

Editor's rating
Editor's rating
  • Editor's rating
    ValuePenguin's team scores insurance companies based on independent research, factoring in customer support, cost, coverage and overall shopping experience.
    4.5/5
  • Full coverage
    Average rate for a typical driver with a clean driving record and good credit. Full methodology.
    $187/mo
Geico is the best because it has an easy-to-use app and website, along with affordable rates.

Go with another company if you prefer to have a personal relationship with an agent or want to bundle your home and auto insurance with the same company.

Geico pros & cons
Price
Cheap
Cheap
Customer service
Average
Average
Good for bundling
Poorly rated home insurance

Best auto insurance discounts: Nationwide

Editor's rating
Editor's rating
  • Editor's rating
    ValuePenguin's team scores insurance companies based on independent research, factoring in customer support, cost, coverage and overall shopping experience.
    4.5/5
  • Full coverage
    Average rate for a typical driver with a clean driving record and good credit. Full methodology.
    $265/mo
Nationwide is the best because of its many discounts, and the company also has good customer service reviews.

Go with another company if you don't want to sign up for a usage-based safe driving program or low-mileage program, as you likely won't be able to get enough savings from discounts unless you use one of these programs.

Nationwide pros & cons
Price
Expensive
Expensive
Customer service
Good
Good
Extra coverage
More than average
Lots of options

Best insurance for military members and veterans: USAA

Editor's rating
Editor's rating
  • Editor's rating
    ValuePenguin's team scores insurance companies based on independent research, factoring in customer support, cost, coverage and overall shopping experience.
    4.5/5
  • Full coverage
    Average rate for a typical driver with a clean driving record and good credit. Full methodology.
    $125/mo
USAA is the best because it has extremely affordable rates and some of the best customer service in the industry.

Go with another company if you're not connected to the military, because only active-duty military members, veterans and some of their family members can get insurance from USAA.

USAA pros & cons
Price
Cheapest
Cheapest
Customer service
Best
Best
Availability
Limited
Limited to drivers with military ties

Car insurance companies that didn’t make our list

Some well-known companies didn't make ValuePenguin's list of top auto insurance companies, including Progressive, Travelers and Allstate. But, one of those could still be a good fit for you.

Progressive

Editor's rating
Editor's rating
  • Editor's rating
    ValuePenguin's team scores insurance companies based on independent research, factoring in customer support, cost, coverage and overall shopping experience.
    3/5
  • Full coverage
    Average rate for a typical driver with a clean driving record and good credit. Full methodology.
    $207/mo

It didn't make our list because:

  • Rates are around average for most people
  • Customer service reviews are typically poor

But, it's worth considering if:

  • You have a DUI
  • You need to buy a policy online quickly

Travelers

Editor's rating
Editor's rating
  • Editor's rating
    ValuePenguin's team scores insurance companies based on independent research, factoring in customer support, cost, coverage and overall shopping experience.
    3/5
  • Full coverage
    Average rate for a typical driver with a clean driving record and good credit. Full methodology.
    $173/mo

It didn't make our list because:

  • It's not typically the cheapest option
  • It gets low scores on J.D. Power surveys

But, it's worth considering if:

Allstate

Editor's rating
Editor's rating
  • Editor's rating
    ValuePenguin's team scores insurance companies based on independent research, factoring in customer support, cost, coverage and overall shopping experience.
    2.5/5
  • Full coverage
    Average rate for a typical driver with a clean driving record and good credit. Full methodology.
    $282/mo

It didn't make our list because:

  • It tends to be very expensive
  • Its claims process can be difficult

But, it's worth considering if:

  • You want to bundle your home and auto policies, because it usually offers cheap home insurance

How customers rank the top insurance companies

NJM, Amica and Erie are the best all-around car insurance companies, according to customers.

Erie logo
Erie has the highest score on J.D. Power's claims satisfaction survey and about half as many complaints as average.

Redditors tend to agree that Erie's combination of great customer service and affordable rates makes it a great choice. Many report staying with Erie for years due to its smooth claims process and great prices.

NJM logo
NJM is ranked third on J.D. Power's claims satisfaction survey, which polls customers about their claims experience. NJM also gets around

In addition, Reddit users write they are very happy with NJM's customer service and claims experience. A few customers even mention their body shops' praise for NJM, saying they tend to pay for original manufacturer parts instead of cheaper aftermarket versions.

Amica logo
Amica is an excellent choice if Amica also earned a high score on J.D. Power's claims satisfaction survey, and it only gets around one-third as many complaints as average.

On Reddit, customers praise Amica for having an outstanding claims process after an accident. And while they admit that Amica can be more expensive than average, Redditors typically agree that its great service is worth the extra cost.

Highest-rated insurance companies according to customers

Company
Overall
Reddit
JD Power
NJM✓✓✓✓
Amica✓✓✓✓
Erie✓✓✓✓
Shelter✓✓✓✓
USAA✓✓✓—
Farm Bureau✓✓—
Auto-Owners✓✓X✓
State Farm✓—✓✓
Nationwide✓X—✓
American Family———✓
Geico————
Travelers——X✓
AAAXX✓—
AllstateXX——
ProgressiveXXX✓
Liberty MutualXXX—
FarmersXXX—
Company
Reddit
JD Power
NJM
Great
Great
Great
Amica
Great
Great
Great
Erie
Great
Great
Great
Shelter
Great
Great
Great
USAA
Great
Great
Average
Auto-Owners
Good
Poor
Good
State Farm
Average
Good
Good
American Family
Average
Average
Good
Geico
Average
Average
Average
Travelers
Average
Poor
Good
Nationwide
Poor
Average
Good
Allstate
Poor
Average
Average
Progressive
Poor
Poor
Good
Liberty Mutual
Poor
Poor
Average
Farmers
Poor
Poor
Average

NR stands for not rated.

Top car insurance companies near you

State Farm is the best-rated major company in

But the best car insurance for you depends on where you live. Auto-Owners is the top choice in while Erie is the best company in and Washington, D.C.

Best motor insurance company near me
Best car and auto insurance by state

Find the Best Cheap Auto Insurance Quotes in Your Area

On means insured, off means not insured.
It's free, simple and secure.

Top auto insurance companies by state

State
Editor's rating
AlabamaAuto-Owners4/5$156
AlaskaState Farm4.5/5$179
ArizonaState Farm4.5/5$203
ArkansasShelter4.25/5$167
CaliforniaAAA4.5/5$176
ColoradoAmerican Family4.5/5$235
ConnecticutState Farm4.5/5$256
DelawareState Farm4.5/5$212
FloridaState Farm4.5/5$215
GeorgiaFarm Bureau4.5/5$134
HawaiiState Farm4.5/5$161
IdahoState Farm4.5/5$85
IllinoisErie4.5/5$141
IndianaAuto-Owners4/5$149
IowaState Farm4.5/5$129
KansasState Farm4.5/5$183
KentuckyState Farm4.5/5$184
LouisianaFarm Bureau4.5/5$312
MaineMMG4.5/5$106
MarylandState Farm4.5/5$180
MassachusettsArbella4.5/5$163
MichiganAuto-Owners4/5$226
MinnesotaAuto-Owners4/5$160
MississippiState Farm4.5/5$142
MissouriShelter4.25/5$186
MontanaState Farm4.5/5$120
NebraskaAuto-Owners4/5$130
NevadaState Farm4.5/5$286
New HampshireMMG4.5/5$127
New JerseyNJM5/5$168
New MexicoState Farm4.5/5$176
New YorkNYCM5/5$157
North CarolinaState Farm4.5/5$89
North DakotaState Farm4.5/5$124
OhioErie4.5/5$113
OklahomaState Farm4.5/5$186
OregonState Farm4.5/5$123
PennsylvaniaErie4.5/5$134
Rhode IslandAmica4/5$306
South CarolinaAuto-Owners4/5$145
South DakotaFarmers Mutual of Nebraska4/5$95
TennesseeAuto-Owners4/5$148
TexasState Farm4.5/5$140
UtahAuto-Owners4/5$160
VermontState Farm4.5/5$92
VirginiaFarm Bureau4.5/5$111
WashingtonMutual of Enumclaw4/5$137
Washington DCErie4.5/5$217
West VirginiaErie4.5/5$135
WisconsinAmerican Family4.5/5$119
WyomingState Farm4.5/5$112

ValuePenguin editors award companies a maximum of five stars based on factors such as cost, coverage availability and customer service reviews.

How much does the best car insurance cost?

The best car insurance company doesn't have to be expensive. However, your rates depend on your coverage, age and driving record.

For example, the best liability-only car insurance comes from Auto-Owners, where a policy costs just $52 per month. But Erie has the best price for full coverage, at $154 per month.

Monthly cost of the best car insurance companies

Best companies
Monthly rate
Erie

4.5/5

$154
American Family

4.5/5

$159
NJM

5/5

$168

Watch: How to compare car insurance companies

How to find the best car insurance for you

The best car insurance company for you should have great coverage and support at an affordable rate in your area.

If your priority is…

savings icon

How to find the best car insurance companies for affordable rates

Shopping around and using discounts are the best ways to lower your car insurance rates.

insurance policy icon

How to find an insurance company with the best coverage

The best auto insurance companies offer extra protection to make your life easier after a crash along with the basic coverage you need to drive legally.

Popular car insurance coverage add-ons

Beyond these basic coverages, insurance companies may offer add-ons. None of these are required by law, so you can choose what you want.

Coverage
Description
Accident forgivenessYour first at-fault accident won't affect your insurance rates.
Vanishing deductibleYour deductible gradually declines for each year you're accident-free.
Mechanical breakdownCovers the cost of repairing wear and tear to your car.
Rideshare insuranceCovers you during the rideshare waiting period when Uber and Lyft coverage doesn't apply.
Gap insuranceIf you lease or finance your car, this covers the difference between the amount you owe and the value of your car if it's totaled.
Roadside assistanceProvides help if your car breaks down, like towing or flat-tire service.
Rental carCovers the cost of a rental car while your car is in the shop after a crash.
customer service icon

How to find the best car insurance for customer support

Start by using ValuePenguin editor recommendations to find the best car insurance companies in the country.

Our five-star ratings are a snapshot of a company's overall quality. Our scores are based on customer service ratings from J.D. Power, customer complaint data from the , cost, coverage options and overall value.

Frequently asked questions

What's the best car insurance company?

American Family is the best car insurance company overall for its affordable rates, excellent service and helpful coverage options. If you want customized coverage, Shelter is a great choice. If you have a teen driver in your family, choose Auto-Owners. And if you recently caused an accident, consider State Farm.

Who has the best car insurance rates?

American Family has the best car insurance rates compared to other major companies. Minimum coverage from American Family costs around $60 per month, and full coverage rates average $159 per month. Companies like USAA, NJM, Erie and Auto-Owners might have cheaper rates, depending on where you live and whether you qualify for coverage.

How can I find the best car insurance for me?

To find the best car insurance for you, figure out how much and what kind of coverage you need. Then get quotes from several companies available near you for the same level of coverage. Compare each company's quotes, customer support ratings, coverage options and discounts.

Who has the best auto insurance near me?

State Farm has the best combination of cheap rates and dependable customer service in 22 states — more than any other company. But the best car insurance in your state might be a smaller local company like Erie or NJM. That's why it pays to compare quotes from several large and small companies near you.

Which insurance company has the best customer satisfaction?

NJM, Amica and Erie are the top-rated car insurance companies for customer satisfaction. All three companies have high scores on J.D. Power's claims satisfaction survey, great reviews on Reddit and earn fewer complaints than average, according to the NAIC.


Methodology

ValuePenguin chose the top 10 insurance companies based on an unbiased review of 40 major insurance companies. All of our picks offer insurance in at least five states.

How companies are rated

ValuePenguin assigned its editor ratings for insurance companies based on customer service, affordability, coverage options and shopping experience.

In addition to doing independent research about each company, we also used additional third-party sources.

  • J.D. Power's 2026 customer survey about overall satisfaction and 2025 claims experience survey
  • AM Best's ratings for a company's financial strength
  • The NAIC's reports on formal complaints about a company, as of July 21, 2026

How costs are calculated

Rates are based on full coverage car insurance using quotes from all residential ZIP codes in the country where the company has a large market share.

Quotes have better coverage than what's required by the states and also include comprehensive and collision coverage to protect your car. Averages are for a 30-year-old man who drives a 2018 Honda Civic EX, unless otherwise noted.

  • Bodily injury liability: $50,000 per person and $100,000 per accident
  • Property damage liability: $50,000 per accident
  • Uninsured and underinsured motorist bodily injury: $50,000 per person and $100,000 per accident
  • Comprehensive and collision coverage: $500 deductible

Family rates for a parent and teenager were gathered separately for all ZIP codes in Illinois, Pennsylvania and Georgia for a 50-year-old with an 18-year-old on their policy. These quotes include the limits above, plus $50,000 of uninsured and underinsured motorist property damage coverage.

How companies are rated

Online experience is based on Apple Store and GooglePlay app ratings, along with ValuePenguin editors' experience using insurance company quote tools.

To find the top car insurance company in each state, ValuePenguin editors chose companies that offer the best combination of cheap rates, reliable customer service, helpful coverage and claims satisfaction data along with customer complaints as reported by the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC).

ValuePenguin's analysis used insurance rate data from Quadrant Information Services. These rates were publicly sourced from insurer filings and should be used for comparative purposes only. Your own quotes may be different.

About the Author

Lindsay Bishop
Lindsay Bishop

Senior Writer

Lindsay Bishop is a Senior Writer at ValuePenguin, where she educates readers about home, auto, renters, flood and motorcycle insurance.


Lindsay began her career in the insurance and financial industry in 2010. She was a licensed auto, home, life and health insurance agent and held Series 6 and 63 financial licenses.


After a hiatus from the financial sector, Lindsay returned to the industry as a content writer for ValuePenguin in 2021. She enjoys having the opportunity to help readers make smart decisions about their insurance so they can be prepared for anything life throws their way.


When Lindsay isn't writing about insurance, you can find her spending time with family, enjoying the outdoors on Sunday long runs or riding her Peloton.

How insurance helped Lindsay


As a homeowner for 15 years located in South Carolina, Lindsay has plenty of experience navigating the coastal insurance market and managing the claims process. That includes successfully negotiating a full roof replacement claim.

Expertise

  • Home insurance
  • Car insurance
  • Flood insurance
  • Renters insurance
  • Motorcycle insurance

Referenced by

  • CNBC
  • Yahoo Finance
  • Miami Herald

Education

  • BS/BA Economics, University of Nevada Las Vegas

Editorial note: The content of this article is based on the author's opinions and recommendations alone. It has not been previewed, commissioned or otherwise endorsed by any of our network partners.

headset-icon
Agents Available
24/7
To speak with a licensed insurance agent and get quotes for car, home, health insurance and more.