State of Auto Insurance in 2023

Car insurance rates are expected to increase by 8.4% across the U.S. in 2023, amid the increase in drivers returning to the road. That's the biggest jump in car insurance costs in the past six years. The average cost of full coverage car insurance across the U.S. is $1,780 per year.

ValuePenguin used the Quadrant Information Services database to analyze millions of quotes for drivers across the U.S. We also analyzed car insurance rate changes filed by top companies across the country to show the current and historical landscape of the auto insurance industry.

Woman announcing 2023 car insurance rate changes

How much does auto insurance cost in my state?

The average cost of full coverage car insurance for 2023 is $1,780 per year.

Auto insurance rates in Michigan average $4,788 a year, the highest in the U.S. and 168% higher than the national average, largely due to the state having the highest minimum insurance requirements.

Florida ($2,856 per year — 60% higher than the national average) and Rhode Island ($2,748 — 53% higher) are the second and third most expensive states for car insurance, thanks to high population density and traffic congestion.

For cheap car insurance, drivers in Vermont ($1,104), Maine ($1,116) and Idaho ($1,188) typically have the most affordable rates across the U.S. Auto insurance in these states is 36% cheaper, on average, than the national average.

Avg annual cost
% over average
Rhode Island$2,74853%
Show All Rows

Average car insurance rate changes by state

Drivers are likely to pay substantially more for car insurance in 2023. The average annual rate increase across the U.S. is 8.4% — up from 1.3% in 2022.

Every state is expected to see a rate increase of at least 1% this year except California, D.C., Hawaii, Vermont and Wyoming.

The biggest year-over-year rate increases are in Illinois (17.1%), Arizona (15.6%), Georgia (13.8%) and New Hampshire (13.6%).

The average cost of car insurance has increased 16.5% overall since 2017.

national auto insurance rate change 2017-2022
S&P data reports rate changes filed by car insurance companies in 2022. Drivers will see rate changes in 2023 when their policies are up for renewal.

How much does a traffic violation increase car insurance costs?

Drivers with a traffic violation or accident could see an average car insurance rate increase of 52% in 2023.

North Carolina has the largest average increase (115%) in full coverage auto insurance rates for drivers with a ticket, accident or DUI on their driving record.

Nebraska auto insurance companies tend to be the most forgiving to drivers with an imperfect driving record, where rates only increase by 35% on average.

A DUI will have the biggest impact on rates, with an average increase of 84% nationwide.

Avg rate increase
At-fault crash
North Carolina115%$1,728$2,052$4,644
New Jersey65%$2,760$3,444$3,264
Show All Rows

Rate increases due to traffic incidents are an average across the incidents analyzed.

Average cost of traffic violations in 2023

Cost of car insurance for the most popular new cars

The cheapest new cars to insure tend to be crossover SUVs and sedans, while pickups and larger SUVs cost more to insure. Smaller sedans and midsize SUVs like the CR-V and RAV4 are typically cheaper to repair or replace than larger cars, so they're typically cheaper to insure.

Electric cars are growing in popularity. The Mini Cooper Electric is one of the cheapest EVs to insure, while Teslas are some of the most expensive. The Porsche Taycan is one of the most expensive cars to insure, as it's both a sports car and an EV.

Cost to insure vehicles by body type

Cost of car insurance for top-selling cars

Car model
Annual cost
Chevy Silverado$2,551
Jeep Grand Cherokee$2,472
GMC Sierra$2,422
Ford F-Series$2,320
Toyota Tacoma$2,308
Toyota Corolla$2,186
Toyota Camry$2,139
Ram Pickup$2,135
Show All Rows

Cost of car insurance for popular EVs

Car model
Annual cost
Porsche Taycan$3,576
Tesla Model Y$3,110
Polestar 2$2,468
Hyundai Ioniq 5$2,425
Rivian R1T$2,340
Show All Rows

2023 car insurance trends

Car insurance companies have begun raising rates for 2023 due to an increase in car repair costs and claims. Many drivers can expect to see a higher car insurance bill this year.

Man looking through binoculars

Return to travel and return to office

Car accidents and claims have increased as more people resume regular travel or return to their daily commute. More people driving means a higher risk of getting in a crash, which means higher car insurance rates.

Rising car costs

Cars are becoming more expensive to repair, in part because replacement parts are becoming difficult to find due to supply shortages or more expensive due to inflation. The lack of availability for used and new cars has also increased the typical market value for many cars, which means insurance companies are paying out higher amounts for claims across the board.

Climate change

Severe storms and hurricanes cause a rise in car insurance claims from cars that are flooded, damaged or destroyed. As the U.S. faces more extreme weather over time, car insurance rates will increase to match a higher risk of damage, especially in coastal areas.

Higher EV sales

The popularity of electric vehicles will only increase as technology improves. However, EVs cost around 28% more to insure than a new gasoline-powered car. Look for vehicle-specific insurance discounts, like electric car and safety feature discounts.

How can I save money on auto insurance in 2023?

Woman using a magnify glass

Compare car insurance quotes

The most important part of searching for car insurance is comparing quotes from several companies. Quotes can vary by hundreds of dollars across companies, even for the same driver.

Woman thinking up ideas

Find car insurance discounts

Insurance companies offer many discounts to help you lower your rates. In the wake of increased remote work, many companies offer discounts or lower rates for driving less. Pay-per-mile car insurance can reduce rates even more for low-mileage drivers.

Man holding a wrench

Adjust your coverage

Switching from full to minimum coverage is a great way to save a significant amount on your car insurance premiums if you don't have a car loan or an expensive car. Full coverage is 157% more expensive than liability-only coverage. Removing optional coverages like roadside assistance can bring down your bill, too.

Man launching a rocket

Improve your credit score

Insurance companies in most states evaluate your credit as a factor for insurance rates. The difference between a good and poor credit score can change premiums by 80%, as people with poor credit may be more likely to file car insurance claims.

About this report

ValuePenguin has a mission to empower people with information and resources to help them make smarter financial decisions. Car insurance can be a difficult and time-consuming topic to understand. This report attempts to unmask some of the critical issues.

In crafting our analysis, we reviewed more than 3.6 million quotes for different drivers, adjusting for various factors that affect auto insurance premiums. We gathered rates from 37 top insurance companies across the country since rates can vary widely by company.

Media Contact
State of auto insurance report methodology

Methodology of this report

Auto insurance rate change data was compiled using RateWatch from S&P Global, which uses annual information from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC).

Quotes are for a 30-year-old man who drives a 2015 Honda Civic EX with good credit and a clean driving record, unless otherwise noted. Quotes include the largest companies in each state from all available ZIP codes. Rates for popular car models are from every ZIP code in Illinois.

ValuePenguin's analysis used insurance rate data from Quadrant Information Services. These rates were publicly sourced from insurer filings and should be used for comparative purposes only, as your quotes may differ.

Quotes are annual costs for full coverage unless otherwise stated. Minimum coverage corresponds to the minimum amounts required by the states. Full coverage quotes include liability coverage plus collision and comprehensive coverage.

Full Coverage Policy

Coverage TypeCoverage limits
Bodily liability$50,000 per person/ $100,000 per accident
Property damage$25,000 per accident
Uninsured/ underinsured motorist BI$50,000 per person/ $100,000 per accident
Comprehensive & collision$500 deductible
Personal injury protectionMinimum when required by state