Who Has the Cheapest Auto Insurance Quotes in Delaware? (2018)

We analyzed auto insurance quotes from the largest insurers to find the best car insurance rates in Delaware. Our research compared annual premiums for a single 30 year old male across nearly forty cities in Delaware. Depending on which company drivers are insured with, local rates could range from $1,176 to $3,710, with the average cost of car insurance in Delaware being $2,044.

Even within the same city, the gap between the most expensive and the cheapest car insurance companies was as high as $4,647-- underscoring the need to comparison shop auto insurance quotes. Read more below, or enter your zip code above to compare quotes from car insurance companies in your area.

Cheap Car Insurance in Delaware

The top five cheapest car insurance companies in Delaware, based on our study of annual premiums, are: GEICO, Atlantic States, and Grange. We compared quotes from auto insurance companies for drivers across dozens of cities in Delaware, and ranked the insurers based on their average cost in the state. The mean cost among the five cheapest local insurers is $1,582 which is a 29% savings compared to the average cost for car insurance in the state.

This graph lists the five cheapest local auto insurance companies underwriting in Delaware, along with their average annual costs, and compares them to the state average.

Find the Cheapest Auto Insurance Quotes in Your Area

Currently Insured?

While your actual car insurance quotes will depend on where you live and park, and your driving record, these companies are good ones to start with if you’re looking for low-cost auto insurance near you in Delaware. Not every company underwrites policyholders the same way, so drivers should always compare quotes between several companies to cover their bases. Here is a table of car insurance companies ranked in the order of lowest average annual insurance costs to the highest:

RankCompanyYearly Car Insurance Rate
1GEICO$1,176
2Atlantic States$1,370
3Grange Insurance$1,684
4Progressive$1,806
5Donegal Mutual$1,877
6MetLife$1,972
7State Farm$2,291
8Encompass$2,513
9Sentry$3,710

Best Car Insurance in Delaware

State Farm, USAA, Liberty Mutual, GEICO, and Progressive were five best auto insurance companies in Delaware. Here’s how we arrived at this conclusion.

To determine which auto insurance companies were the best in Delaware, we looked at complaints submitted to the State of Delaware's Department of Insurance as a measure of drivers' customer satisfaction. We assumed that the companies with the least complaints as a proportion of their business (and as compared to the competition) would be doing the best jobs keeping their policyholders satisfied. We calculated this complaint index by dividing a company’s share of complaints by their share of business, and then ranked them from the lowest index number (best) to highest (worst). To be relevant to most consumers, we only looked at large companies in Delaware.

RankGroup NamePhysical Damage PremiumsClosed ComplaintsIndex
1State Farm Insurance Group$43,387,914100.39
2USAA / United Services Automobile Association12,074,73340.55
3Liberty Mutual Insurance Group18,768,11970.62
4GEICO Insurance Group22,110,36690.68
5Progressive Insurance Group12,947,70460.78
6Nationwide Insurance Group25,084,664171.13
7Metropolitan Group Property & Casualty Insurance Company1,438,66711.16
8Hartford Insurance Group3,994,43031.26
921st Century Centennial Insurance Company5,877,07661.71
10Travelers Auto Insurance Group3,376,98941.98
11Farm Family Casualty Insurance Company1,176,17722.85
12Donegal Mutual Insurance Company1,558,04233.22
13Titan Auto Insurance2,543,91363.95

Auto Insurance in Delaware: Minimum Coverage Requirements

Delaware requires that car insurance policies include, at minimum, the following limits of coverage:

  • Bodily Injury (BI) Liability: $25,000 per person / $50,000 per accident
  • Property Damage (PD) Liability: $10,000 per accident
  • Personal Injury Protection (PIP): $15,000 per person / $30,000 per accident

While these limits represent the least amount of insurance coverage you can have, you should consider adding more, as damages above these limits could require that you pay out-of-pocket. The amount of liability insurance you should have typically depends upon the amount of assets you have at risk in the case of a lawsuit. For example, if you own a house in an expensive neighborhood and have sizable savings, we'd recommend you increase your liability limits and consider adding umbrella insurance as well.

Cheap Car Insurance in Delaware: by City

The cost of auto insurance varies significantly from city to city, and can even differ by hundreds of dollars between insurers within the same city. The cheapest city in our Delaware analysis was Lewes, with an average local cost of $1,830, while the most expensive was Wilmington, at $3,185. In Wilmington, prices differed by as much as $4,647 per year. Take a look at the three cheapest auto insurance companies by city in our table below.

CityCompanyYearly Car Insurance Rate
Bear Atlantic States $1,320
GEICO $1,390
Grange Insurance $1,980
Bethany Beach GEICO $1,116
Atlantic States $1,320
Grange Insurance $1,596
Bridgeville GEICO $1,116
Atlantic States $1,320
Grange Insurance $1,596
Camden Wyoming GEICO $1,171
Atlantic States $1,320
Grange Insurance $1,596
Claymont GEICO $1,418
Atlantic States $1,560
Grange Insurance $1,980
Clayton GEICO $1,116
Atlantic States $1,320
Grange Insurance $1,596
Dagsboro GEICO $1,116
Atlantic States $1,320
Grange Insurance $1,596
Delmar GEICO $1,116
Atlantic States $1,320
Grange Insurance $1,596
Dover GEICO $1,171
Atlantic States $1,320
Grange Insurance $1,596
Ellendale GEICO $1,116
Atlantic States $1,320
Grange Insurance $1,596
Felton GEICO $1,116
Atlantic States $1,320
Grange Insurance $1,596
Frankford GEICO $1,116
Atlantic States $1,320
Grange Insurance $1,596
Frederica GEICO $1,116
Atlantic States $1,320
Grange Insurance $1,596
Georgetown GEICO $1,116
Atlantic States $1,320
Grange Insurance $1,596
Greenwood GEICO $1,116
Atlantic States $1,320
Grange Insurance $1,596
Harrington GEICO $1,116
Atlantic States $1,320
Grange Insurance $1,596
Hartly GEICO $1,116
Atlantic States $1,320
Grange Insurance $1,596
Hockessin GEICO $1,339
Atlantic States $1,560
Grange Insurance $1,980
Laurel GEICO $1,116
Atlantic States $1,320
Grange Insurance $1,596
Lewes GEICO $1,116
Atlantic States $1,320
Grange Insurance $1,596
Lincoln GEICO $1,116
Atlantic States $1,320
Grange Insurance $1,596
Magnolia GEICO $1,116
Atlantic States $1,320
Grange Insurance $1,596
Middletown GEICO $1,116
Atlantic States $1,320
Grange Insurance $1,596
Milford GEICO $1,116
Atlantic States $1,320
Grange Insurance $1,596
Millsboro GEICO $1,116
Atlantic States $1,320
Grange Insurance $1,596
Milton GEICO $1,116
Atlantic States $1,320
Grange Insurance $1,596
New Castle Atlantic States $1,320
GEICO $1,390
Donegal Mutual $1,800
Newark Atlantic States $1,560
GEICO $1,575
Grange Insurance $1,980
Ocean View GEICO $1,116
Atlantic States $1,320
Grange Insurance $1,596
Rehoboth Beach GEICO $1,116
Atlantic States $1,320
Grange Insurance $1,596
Seaford GEICO $1,116
Atlantic States $1,320
Grange Insurance $1,596
Selbyville GEICO $1,116
Atlantic States $1,320
Grange Insurance $1,596
Smyrna GEICO $1,116
Atlantic States $1,320
Grange Insurance $1,596
Townsend GEICO $1,116
Atlantic States $1,320
Grange Insurance $1,596
Wilmington GEICO $1,569
Progressive $2,250
Atlantic States $2,364

Find the Cheapest Auto Insurance Quotes in Your Area

Currently Insured?

Wilmington, DE

Delaware’s largest city is home to 71,000 residents, and ranks as the most expensive city in our study. It’s the headquarters of major credit card businesses and the conglomerate Dupont, and hosts the Clifford Brown Jazz Festival. It can cost on average $3,158 to insure a vehicle garaged in Wilmington each year.

If you’re looking for cheap car insurance in Wilmington, start by getting quotes GEICO, Progressive and Atlantic States. These companies ranked with three of the lowest costs in Wilmington, and averaged about $2,061 a year in insurance premiums, or about 53% less than the city average.

This graph shows the five cheapest auto insurers in Wilmington (GEICO, Progressive, Atlantic States, Grange Insurance and MetLife), and compares them to the average cost in the city

Dover, DE

Dover is the second largest city and capitol of the First State. Dover International Speedway and Dover Downs are two popular automobile racetracks in the city, with the Monster Mile hosting two NASCAR races a year. The Dover Air Force Base is also located here (we break the AFB out separately in our table above). The cost of auto insurance here in Dover is cheaper than average at $2,003 a year. We found that local drivers could save up to 47% when insuring with three companies in particular: GEICO, Atlantic States and Grange Insurance. The average annual rate with these insurers was $1,362.

This graph shows the top five lowest cost insurers and their average costs in Dover.

Newark, DE

Lying midway between Philadelphia and Baltimore is the city of Newark. It measures nine square miles in area, and is surrounded by verdant parks, with ample green space from White Clay Creek State Park to Glasgow Park. The city is served by several interstate highways, including the I-95 and Route 896, which makes it convenient for the city's 32,000 residents to drive and commute about. It's also site of the main campus of the University of Delaware and a major hub for figure skating. It costs on average $2,620 a year to cover your car in Delaware’s third largest city. Residents here can pay costs that are 21% higher than elsewhere in the state, which ranks the city as the 2nd most expensive spot in Delaware. People looking for affordable car insurance quotes near you should consider Atlantic States, GEICO and Grange Insurance which had three of the lowest auto insurance premiums in Newark at an average price of $1,705. Going with these local companies could shave 54% off of what the typical driver in Newark pays.

This chart lists the five cheapest auto insurers in Newark, DE by their annual premiums.

Middletown, DE

Middletown once played host to the filming of the “Dead Poets Society” – the city’s St. Andrews School served as the main setting for the bulk of its scenes. Depending on when residents drive around, they can find streets blocked off from several annual parades and events. Among these are the Old Tyme Peach Festival, the Big Ball Marathon, and the Hummers Parade. Drivers in Middletown can pay average rates of about $2,057 for car insurance – just around the state average. We recommend that consumers start with quotes at GEICO, Atlantic States and Grange Insurance, which had the three lowest auto insurance costs in Middletown. Together, they had an average cost of $1,193 for the Middletown driver – a reduction of 34% compared to the citywide average. For reference, the three most expensive carriers in town had a mean annual premium of $4,096, which would still cost more than getting insured at Allianz, Ameriprise, and MetLife combined!

This graph displays the top five cheapest companies in Middletown for car insurance based on our sample drivers

Smyrna, DE

Smyrna is home to 10,000 residents, and is centrally located between the state capital of Dover, and south of Newark and Wilmington. Most recently, the town announced the construction of a solar power generation building aimed at creating more renewable energy sources and lowering costs. The typical single male in his early 30s could see annual rates here of $1,983 on average, which is 3% lower than the Delaware mean. When it comes to lowering car insurance costs, we recommend GEICO, Atlantic States, and Grange. Going with these three insurers would cost on average $1,344 and could reduce drivers’ costs by 48%. On the other hand, making the mistake of going with the three most expensive companies in Smyrna would have cost you about $3,000 more each year.

This chart displays the five most affordable auto insurance companies in Smyrna, DE and ranks them from the cheapest up.

Milford, DE

The town of Milford started from a mill powered by the crossing of the Mispillion River. Motorists in this town of 9,800 pay premiums of about $1,883 a year to insure their cars, or 19% cheaper than elsewhere in the state. For affordable auto insurance in Milford, GEICO, Atlantic States and Grange are three good companies for locals to start comparison shopping for quotes. The average among those three insurers is $1,344, making them $539 cheaper than what the typical insurer charged in the city.

This graph displays and ranks the five lowest cost providers for auto insurance in Milford

Seaford, DE

The first occupants of Seaford relied on the Nanticoke River as their main means of transport, and it wasn’t until 1720 that roads were started. Today, those roads are better paved and more frequently traveled. Drivers in Seaford can pay about $1,936 when it comes to auto insurance. While it is generally cheaper to insure a car in Seaford compared to other cities in Delaware (by about 6%), there is always room for additional savings. We found that GEICO, Atlantic States and Grange Insurance were the companies with cheapest auto insurance in Seaford. Together the three had an annual premium of $1,344, 44% less than the city average.

This graph shows which auto insurance companies in Seaford have the lowest annual rates.

Georgetown, DE

Georgetown is located in Sussex County, and was established in 1791 in an effort to designate a centralized county seat convenient for all citizens to travel to. It costs today $1,936 a year to protect residents' cars with liability coverage, or about 6% cheaper than the Delaware average. Affordable auto insurance near you in Georgetown can be found at GEICO, Atlantic States and Grange Insurance where costs averaged $1,344, or $591 less than the average of other insurers. That's also $2,940 cheaper on average than going with one of the three most expensive companies in Georgetown.

From GEICO and onwards, Georgetown’s five cheapest auto insurance companies are identified and compared in this graph

New Castle, DE

The city was once ruled by Swedish, Dutch, and English settlers. Today, its population numbers 5,300 and its average cost of car insurance is $2,486 a year, or 18% higher than the average in Delaware. For cheap car insurance in New Castle, go with Atlantic States, GEICO, and Donegal Mutual (average annual premium: $1,503). In comparison, the three priciest companies have an average cost of $2,574 a year.

This graph showcases the five auto insurance companies in New Castle, DE, with the lowest annual rates

Bethany Beach, DE

One of the cheapest places for car insurance in Delaware is Bethany Beach, a town of 1,000 residents. Recognizable by its landmark totem pole statue, the town is a beach resort area popular in the summertime. Auto insurance here costs $1,834 a year – about 11% cheaper than its other neighbors in the state. Between GEICO, Atlantic States and Grange Insurance, the three cheapest, your auto insurance rates would be 36% under the city average. Just make sure to comparison shop - winding up with one of the expensive insurers could cost you $2,116 a year.

This graph lays out the five cheapest companies for auto insurance in Bethany Beach, and compares them to the city average.

Ocean View, DE

Bordered by the Atlantic Ocean, a bay, a canal, and a creek, the town of Ocean View is a seaside community and the second best city for auto insurance. Its 1,900 residents pay a total of $1,834 for automobile insurance, which makes costs here 11% cheaper than elsewhere in the state. If you're looking for low cost automobile insurance in Ocean View, we recommend getting quotes from GEICO, Atlantic States and Grange Insurance. Together their average cost is $1,344, which is $490 lower than the citywide average.

This bar graph identifies the names and average costs for the cheapest auto insurance companies in Ocean View

Cost of Car Insurance in Delaware: by City

How much does it cost to insure a car in Delaware? We found that the overall average across the state was $2,044 for a single man in his early 30s. Annual premiums can vary by as much as $1,830 in Lewes to to $3,185 in Wilmington. This graph below illustrates the average cost in each city in Delaware for our sample driver.

This graph shows the average annual cost to insure a car in over fifty cities in Delaware

Methodology

We analyzed quotes from 35 cities in Delaware for a single 30 year old male who hasn't had any accidents or traffic violations within the last three years. Our sample motorist drove 12,000 miles a year. We chose insurance limits a bit above the state minimum required in Delaware.

CoverageStudy Liability Coverage
Bodily Injury Protection$50,000 / $100,000
Property Damage$50,000
Personal Injury Protection$50,000 / $100,000
Uninsured Motorist$50,000 / $100,000
Comprehensive Coverage$500 deductible
Collision Coverage$500 deductible

Comments and Questions