Stacked vs. Unstacked Car Insurance: Which is Better?

Stacking insurance is a way to raise your coverage if you are in an accident with an uninsured or underinsured driver. Stacked insurance allows you to combine coverage limits either from multiple policies or from multiple cars on the same policy.

Only uninsured motorist (UM) or underinsured motorist (UIM) bodily injury coverage can be stacked. You cannot stack UM and UIM property damage coverage. Currently, 32 states allow some form of stacking insurance, although not all companies offer the option even in states that do.

What is stacked vs. unstacked insurance?

Stacked insurance is a way to combine insurance coverage limits from multiple policies or multiple vehicles. However, the only coverage that can be stacked is bodily injury uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage.

When insurance policies are stacked, their coverage limits are added together. There are two ways to stack coverages:

Stacking across multiple policies

When your name is on multiple insurance policies, you may be able to stack, or add together, the uninsured motorist coverage limits. This comes into play when you have your own insurance policy and your name is also on another policy, like that of a spouse or family member. This is sometimes called vertical stacking. Stacking your policies this way does, however, result in slightly higher premiums.

Stacking within one auto insurance policy

If you have multiple vehicles insured on the same policy, you can pay more and opt to stack the uninsured or underinsured coverage. Since each vehicle has its own coverage limit, those limits can be stacked. This is sometimes called horizontal stacking.

For example, say you own two cars, both insured on the same auto policy. Each one has $15,000 of underinsured motorist coverage. If you pay to stack the policies, you'll have $30,000 in potential coverage should you get into an accident with an uninsured driver while driving one of them.

States where you can stack insurance

Stacking is allowed in 32 states, though the laws for stacking insurance vary by state. Some have certain restrictions on how policies can be stacked.

States that allow both kinds of stacking

States that only allow vertical stacking

A few states have unique rules to know about when it comes to stacking insurance. For instance, Pennsylvania and Florida allow drivers to waive the ability to stack their insurance when they are purchasing their policy.

States that do not permit insurance stacking at all

Do all insurers offer stacked insurance?

Not all insurance companies offer stacked insurance, even in states where it is allowed. Certain states allow insurers to add anti-stacking language into policies.

This isn't always the case — some states by law prohibit "anti-stacking language" in insurance policies. We suggest you ask about stacking opportunities and limitations when comparing insurance quotes.

You can ask specifically about your options and if you have any flexibility when it comes to raising your uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage.

Should you stack your uninsured motorist insurance?

You should only stack your car insurance if it's more affordable than buying an equivalent level of unstacked coverage. For example, a stacked $10,000 per person/$20,000 per accident limit across two cars provides the same level of coverage as an unstacked 20/40 policy. As a result, you should choose whichever is cheaper.

However, it's not always the case that stacking your insurance will be cheaper than buying an unstacked policy with equivalent coverage.

For example, we found that in Florida, the cost of a stacked 10/20 policy for two cars is often higher than an unstacked 20/40 policy.

Each provides the same level of coverage, but in this case, it makes more sense to choose the second option.

Cost of stacked vs. unstacked uninsured motorist coverage

Note that Florida has more uninsured drivers than nearly all other states, so the cost of stacking uninsured motorist coverage is higher there than in other places.

If stacking is not permitted in your state, or you are unable to stack policies, an alternative is to increase your uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage limits. This will similarly cost more, but it offers more security if you find yourself in an accident with a driver who cannot cover the damage.

Methodology

ValuePenguin's analysis used insurance rate data from Quadrant Information Services. These rates were publicly sourced from insurer filings and should be used for comparative purposes only — your own quotes may be different.

All sample quotes are based on statewide averages in Florida among Allstate, Geico and State Farm.