shield logo
Find Insurers
arrow logo

.

Best Cheapest Auto Insurance Quotes in Miami, Florida

Best Cheapest Auto Insurance Quotes in Miami, Florida

Minimum coverage auto insurance in Miami costs an average of $3,788, or $316 per month. The average price of a full coverage policy is $5,094, or $425 per month.

Miami drivers may find a cheaper car insurance policy with Geico, which provides quotes well under 50% of the city average.

Find Cheap Auto Insurance Quotes in Miami

Currently insured?

To save as much money as possible in Florida’s Magic City, you should compare quotes and policies from multiple insurers.

Cheapest auto insurance in Miami: Geico

Geico had the most affordable rates for Miami drivers at an average annual cost of $1,501 — about $2,287 less than the city average.

The next cheapest option is State Farm, but it's approximately double the price of Geico’s minimum insurance policy.

This graph identifies and ranks the three companies in Miami with the best rates for insuring our sample drivers' cars

Find Cheap Auto Insurance Quotes in Miami

Currently insured?

The cheapest auto insurance plan a driver can get is a minimum liability policy, which provides the lowest amount of coverage a state requires drivers to hold in order to legally operate a vehicle. Florida has the second-highest minimum liability policy in the country.

Rank
Company
Average annual premium
1Geico$1,501
2State Farm$3,110
3Direct General$3,336
4MetLife$3,520
5Progressive$4,891
6Allstate$6,369

Although the cheapest coverage option is a minimum policy, this may not necessarily be the best for your needs or background. For example, drivers insured under a minimum coverage policy are not financially protected from damage caused by storms or hurricanes.

Miami residents who own new vehicles or cars worth more than $3,000 should invest in higher coverage limits or additional protection options.

Cheapest Miami full coverage policy: Geico

Geico has the cheapest full coverage plan at $2,166 per year. That's $665 more than its minimum coverage policy.

The closest alternative is State Farm, which has an average full coverage policy cost of $4,167.

Rank
Company
Average annual premium
1Geico$2,166
2State Farm$4,167
3Direct General$4,502
4Progressive$5,971
5MetLife$6,711
6Allstate$7,047

A full coverage policy is one that encompasses the financial protections offered by a minimum liability policy as well as collision and comprehensive coverage.

  • Financially protects against damages caused by "acts of God" or by circumstances out of your control
  • Provides coverage for natural disasters, vandalism, theft, explosions, broken windows and falling objects
  • Financially protects against damages caused by crashing your car into another object or vehicle
  • Provides coverage when you crash into a pole, your car flips over or you are involved in a hit-and-run

Cheapest car insurance for young Miami drivers: Geico

Young drivers searching for affordable car insurance in Miami should check out Geico, which has an average premium rate of $4,262.

Rank
Company
Average annual premium
1Geico$4,262
2Direct General$6,654
3State Farm$7,847
4MetLife$9,228
5Progressive$12,361
6Allstate$13,212

The cheapest full coverage policy for a young person is more expensive than the city average. Insurance rates tend to be higher if you are a new and inexperienced driver because you are statistically more likely to be involved in an accident.

Young drivers have to navigate the pricey landscape of insurance in Florida, oftentimes with a limited budget. There are a few ways you can make your insurance more affordable.

Here are a few ways save money on auto insurance:

  • Obtain a combined or multi-car policy with your family. Ask your parents, or an older driver in your family, if you can sign onto their insurance plan. Having a young person on their policy will increase their insurance premium. However, it’s more than $2,000 cheaper on average than having two separate plans.
  • Ask about discounts. Most insurers have a list of discounts drivers can qualify for. If you fulfill the eligibility criteria of multiple discounts, the savings will add up. Be aware that smaller companies have more limited discount offers compared to larger insurers.
  • Shop around. Being insured under a large or widely available company isn’t always the best option. Consider looking into small insurers to see if they offer better premium estimates. While they may not offer many discounts, their rates may be cheap enough to compensate.

Cheapest insurance in Miami for drivers with accident histories

Out of six major insurers in Miami, Geico and State Farm increased their rates the least after an accident.

Depending on your insurer, you may see a jump in premium costs of up to several thousands of dollars after an accident.

MetLife, the most expensive insurer, increased prices for their drivers by nearly 60% after an accident — a whopping $3,996 difference.

Rank
Company
Rate before accident
Rate after accident
Difference
1Geico$2,166$3,162$996
2State Farm$4,167$4,990$823
3Direct General$4,502$6,081$1,579
4Progressive$5,971$8,467$2,496
5Allstate$7,047$10,143$3,996
6MetLife$6,711$10,707$3,996

Accidents are unpredictable; you never know when you might be involved in one. Having an accident on your record affects your rates tremendously, which is why we recommend comparing car insurance from multiple insurers and looking for extra discounts.

Best insurance company customer service in Miami, Florida

Our survey of customer satisfaction found that the Miami insurer with the most positive service feedback is Allstate, as 64% of customers expressed that they were extremely satisfied with their experience.

Another large insurer with similar ratings is State Farm, with 59% of customers saying they were satisfied with their experience.

Miami drivers should consider insurers that have top-ranked customer service. Even if a company has low insurance rates, it may not be enough to make up for long claims processes, lagging or nonexistent response times or rude agents.

Best auto insurers in Florida, by complaints

The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC), measures the quality of a company’s customer service by the frequency of formal complaints it receives from drivers. The companies with the fewest customer complaints according to the NAIC are:

  • Amica
  • Farm Bureau
  • Southern-Owners
  • Progressive

The national median for the NAIC's Complaint Index is 1.0, meaning companies with a lower index generally provide better customer service.

Rank
Company
Complaint index
1Amica0.06
2Florida Farm Bureau0.07
3Southern-Owners0.10
4Progressive0.10
5Safeco0.11
Show All Rows

Average cost of minimum insurance by Miami area

Insurance rates can fluctuate even depending on the area of the city you reside in. Each neighborhood in Miami differs in terms of crime rate, accident rate and population density. As a result, policy premiums can vary by more than $1,000.

For example, the average resident of South Miami, one of the most inexpensive areas of the city, pays approximately $3,128 for a minimum policy. Meanwhile, Little Havana, one of the most expensive neighborhoods, is a major cultural center of Miami where residents pay an average of $4,425 for auto insurance.

ZIP code
Neighborhood
Average annual car insurance rate
33122Doral$4,109
33125Little Havana$4,425
33126Flagami$4,264
33127Wynwood / Model City$4,033
33128East Little Havana$4,179
Show All Rows
Compare Rates

Minimum coverage requirement in Miami, Florida

The minimum car insurance requirement is set by the state of Florida. All Miami drivers are required to have the following coverages to legally drive in the state:

Coverage type
Minimum limit
Personal injury protection (PIP)$10,000 per accident
Property damage liability (PDL)$10,000 per accident

Considering Florida’s high insurance rates, it’s understandable that drivers might opt for the minimum amount of coverage, since that is the cheapest option. However, it may not meet your individual needs.

Drivers whose cars are less than 10 years old or worth more than $3,000 should consider opting for additional coverage. If you get into an expensive accident with insufficient coverage, you can end up paying out-of-pocket costs.

Florida’s no-fault law

No-fault states require insurers to provide coverage for medical costs regardless of who is at fault in an accident. Florida is one of these states. This no-fault coverage comes in the form of PIP liability.

PIP covers up to 80% of medical expenses and 60% of lost income if you are unable to work, with a combined limit of $10,000.

No-fault insurance is distinct from liability coverage because the latter pays other parties when you are found at fault in an accident.

Methodology

Auto insurance quote data was collected from six insurance companies located in Miami. Our sample driver is a 30-year-old man who, unless explicitly stated, received quotes for a minimum liability policy. During instances where a full coverage policy was analyzed, the following limits were applied:

Coverage type
Study limits
Bodily liability$50,000 per person / $100,000 per accident
Property damage$25,000 per accident
Uninsured/underinsured motorist bodily injury$50,000 per person / $100,000 per accident
Comprehensive and collision$500 deductible

ValuePenguin's analysis used insurance rate data from Quadrant Information Services. These rates were publicly sourced from insurer filings and should be used for comparative purposes only — your own quotes may be different.

Editorial Note: The content of this article is based on the author’s opinions and recommendations alone. It has not been previewed, commissioned or otherwise endorsed by any of our network partners.