The Best and Cheapest Motorcycle Insurance Companies in New York

Find the Cheapest Motorcycle Insurance Quotes in Your Area

Currently insured?
{"id":6,"isAgeFieldVisible":true,"isInsuranceTypeFieldVisible":true,"isInsuredStatusFieldVisible":true,"customEventLabel":"","defaultZip":"","defaultProduct":"motorcycle","quoteWizardEndpoint":"https:\/\/quotes.valuepenguin.com","trackingKey":"_best-cheap-motorcycle-insurance-new","title":"Find the Cheapest Motorcycle Insurance Quotes in Your Area","vendor":"vp"}

We collected hundreds of motorcycle insurance quotes across the state of New York and found that Nationwide is the best for most people. Its rates are 38% less than the statewide average price we found, $959.

We also recommend GEICO for customers who want the lowest price for their motorcycle insurance, especially people who live in New York City. While the average rate we found for New York City motorcycle insurance was a staggering $2,208 per year, GEICO's motorcycle insurance rates were more than $1,000 cheaper than the average.

The best motorcycle insurance companies in New York state

When evaluating the best motorcycle insurance companies in New York, we looked at price, coverage options, customer service and financial stability in order to find the best for most people, alongside alternative picks for people with more specialized needs.

Best for most people: Nationwide

Our top choice for motorcycle insurance for motorcyclists in New York state is Nationwide. It offered a very competitive rate across New York, with an average price of $598 per year. That's 38% less than the average we found across all insurers.

We were also impressed with Nationwide's customer service ratings and coverage options. It had an impressively low complaint index of 0.49 from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC), meaning that it received about half as many complaints as a typical insurer. And it offers a nice array of coverage options and discounts, such as a "disappearing" deductible: For each year you go claim-free, your deductible goes down by $100.

As a major national insurer, Nationwide offers a broad range of insurance products, including home, auto and life insurance. You may be able to reduce your rate even more by bundling your insurance policies.

Best for lowest rates: GEICO

Motorcyclists focused on getting the lowest price for motorcycle insurance should start with GEICO. With an annual price of $547 for motorcycle insurance, it was 43% cheaper than the typical motorcycle insurer in New York. It was also $41 cheaper than Nationwide, our overall top pick.

Because of how expensive motorcycle insurance is in NYC, we recommend GEICO to New York City residents, in particular. We found that motorcycle insurance costs in NYC are 130% higher than across New York state. With a citywide average of $1,148, GEICO offers savings of $1,060 when compared to the typical NYC price.

However, GEICO's coverage options and discounts available aren't as plentiful as other competing insurers. For example, it doesn't offer a discount for being in a motorcycle affinity group, or offer an OEM parts coverage option.

On the plus side, GEICO has a wide variety of different insurance products, so you can bundle your motorcycle, car and home insurance policies together, if you want. Doing so does get you a discount, and it simplifies the process of managing your insurance policies.

Best coverage options: Markel

For motorcycle owners who want the best coverage options and are less focused on the lowest price, we recommend Markel insurance. For instance, Markel includes mechanical breakdown coverage for some motorcycles — which covers the cost to repair your motorcycle, even if the damage isn't due to a crash. And you can buy up to $30,000 of coverage for accessories and add-ons, too.

Its rates were not as affordable as our top picks, but still slightly cheaper than average — the typical price we found from Markel was $921, or $38 cheaper than the average, overall.

Markel's other downside is that as a specialty insurance company, it doesn't offer regular car insurance and the potential savings of a bundle deal. If you own a car in addition to your motorcycle, you'll need to find coverage for that vehicle with another insurer.

The best reviewed motorcycle insurance companies in New York

When considering motorcycle insurance companies, a low price shouldn't be your only consideration — customer service and financial stability matter, too. With that in mind, we collected the National Association of Insurance Commissioners Complaint Index and A.M. Best financial strength rating of five of the top New York motorcycle insurers. The NAIC complaint index measures how frequently a company is the subject of a complaint to the NAIC; the A.M. Best rating judges how sound a company's financial footing is.

InsurerNAIC complaint indexA.M. Best rating
Progressive0.88A+
Nationwide0.49A+
GEICO0.92A++
Dairyland1.16A+
Markel0*A
Markel did not receive any personal passenger vehicle insurance complaints in 2018. However, as a specialty insurer, it also has a very small market share, so its score of 0 may be an anomaly.

Note that the NAIC combines automobile and motorcycle insurance into a single industry category; as such, these complaint indexes are based on each company's combined premium dollars for motorcycles and cars.

The cheapest motorcycle insurance companies in New York

We collected hundreds of motorcycle insurance quotes across dozens of cities in New York to determine which motorcycle insurer offers the lowest rates. GEICO offered the most affordable rates, with a typical price of $547 per year.

Column chart comparing the average costs of the most affordable motorcycle insurance companies in New York

New York Motorcycle Insurance Requirements

All motorcycle riders in the state of New York are required to have liability insurance. Unlike with automobiles, motorcycle insurance policies are not required to include personal injury protection (PIP) or uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage. Below, we've included a breakdown of New York's motorcycle insurance requirements.

Coverage typeMinimum limit
Bodily Injury Liability$25,000 per person / $50,000 per accident
Death Liability$50,000 per person / $100,000 per accident
Property Damage Liability$10,000

Motorcycle insurance costs: City-by-city breakdown

To help New York motorcyclists get an accurate understanding of how much motorcycle insurance costs, we calculated the average cost of insurance in 84 cities and neighborhoods across the state. For each place, we've included the average cost, as well as how it compares to the statewide average cost.

CityAverage cost% difference from state average
Albany$836.07-13.68%
Amherst$776.76-8.73%
Amityville$1,122.0218.35%
Amsterdam$631.99-43.34%
Auburn$622.63-30.84%
Babylon$1,099.2520.67%
Bath$631.99-54.07%
Bayside, New York City$2,069.35100.13%
Binghamton$775.07-30.63%
Brooklyn, New York City$2,504.0474.20%
Buffalo$897.42-9.19%
Callicoon$725.59-9.71%
Cold Spring$682.32-31.90%
Cooperstown$725.59-33.50%
Corning$631.99-49.34%
Dunkirk$631.99-46.39%
East Hampton$937.52-4.92%
Ellenville$837.87-20.69%
Ellicottville$691.78-29.53%
Elmira$631.99-40.18%
Fresh Meadows, New York City$2,069.35159.12%
Fulton$631.99-53.27%
Garden City$1,139.068.24%
Geneva$631.99-53.27%
Glens Falls$682.42-25.13%
Gloversville$631.99-53.27%
Herkimer$631.99-49.33%
Hornell$631.99-53.27%
Ithaca$631.99-53.27%
Kingston$691.78-43.81%
Lawrence$1,266.9747.21%
Le Roy$631.99-48.66%
Lewisboro$949.32-1.52%
Lindenhurst$1,139.0626.97%
Little Falls$691.78-29.16%
Long Island City, New York City$2,504.04134.80%
Manhattan, New York City$2,301.29192.64%
Massapequa$1,116.295.90%
Mattituck$843.93-5.42%
Mayville$631.99-30.16%
Melville$1,099.2515.48%
Middletown$888.90-12.62%
Millerton$751.09-19.79%
Mineola$1,139.0619.17%
Nanuet$833.10-18.04%
Narrowsburg$842.16-11.10%
New City$904.62-7.68%
New York City average$2,197.91113.05%
Newark$631.99-39.97%
Newburgh$2,069.35121.68%
Niagara Falls$855.27-17.94%
Norwich$691.78-13.38%
Nyack$927.39-4.82%
Olean$621.34-50.20%
Oneida$631.99-36.30%
Oneonta$725.59-39.12%
Orchard Park$776.76-30.36%
Oswego$631.99-46.39%
Pelham$1,219.8832.35%
Plattsburgh$622.63-54.75%
Port Chester$848.68-9.83%
Poughkeepsie$800.57-26.99%
Ridgewood, New York City$2,373.57165.54%
Rochester$939.99-3.58%
Rockaway Point, New York City$1,973.4642.33%
Rome$631.99-35.81%
Rye Brook$920.43-2.44%
Sag Harbor$937.52-4.92%
Saratoga Springs$716.23-27.42%
Schenectady$761.09-22.14%
Setauket$963.02-0.78%
Southampton$903.72-8.53%
Staten Island, New York City$1,610.6266.66%
Sunnyside, New York City$2,504.04169.90%
Syracuse$810.57-9.81%
Tonawanda$810.57-6.31%
Troy$810.57-19.50%
Utica$667.49-37.15%
Watertown$725.59-29.98%
Wellsville$631.99-50.43%
West Seneca$810.57-21.78%
Westfield$631.99-53.27%
Westhampton$937.52-3.84%
White Plains$1,087.4118.79%
Williamsville$776.76-20.46%

Study Methodology

We collected 420 motorcycle insurance quotes from five major motorcycle insurance companies that operate in New York state. Our sample rider was a 45-year-old man who rides a 2019 Harley-Davidson Street Glide. The coverage limits we included are:

  • Bodily injury liability coverage: $100,000 per person/$300,000 per accident
  • Property damage liability coverage: $50,000 per accident
  • Collision coverage: Included/$500 deductible
  • Comprehensive coverage: Included/$500 deductible
  • All other coverages: Not included

Comments and Questions

Editorial Note: The content of this article is based on the author’s opinions and recommendations alone. It has not been previewed, commissioned or otherwise endorsed by any of our network partners.