Home Insurance Facts and Statistics: Coverage & Claims

At least 85% of homeowners in the U.S. have homeowners insurance, and policies cost an average of $1,445 per year. It’s not a required form of coverage by the government, but home insurance is typically required as a condition of having a mortgage. It is very valuable in terms of the protection it offers homeowners.

Home insurance policies generally cover damage to a home's structure, damage to your personal property and liability coverage in case you're considered at fault for property damage or bodily injury to another party. Below are some key facts and figures on home insurance policyholders, the cost of coverage, home insurance claims and other statistics to give you a better sense of the market.

Homeowners insurance coverage purchased

Homeowners insurance is a valuable policy option that provides coverage for not just the house but also its contents and the owner's liability. Approximately 85% of homeowners have home insurance policies, according to data from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC), 79.09% of which are HO-3 policies.

HO-1 and HO-2 are considered “named perils” policies, meaning they only cover damage caused by a peril specifically named in the policy, such as theft.

HO-3 and HO-5 policies, on the other hand, are called “open peril” policies. They cover any cause of damage to your home's structure except those specifically excluded within the policy. HO-8 policies are generally limited to older, higher-value homes.

Unfortunately, a ValuePenguin survey found that 47% of homeowners are unsure of what their insurance covers. J.D. Power similarly found that 52% of homeowners don't completely understand their coverage. Homeowners also have trouble identifying the replacement value of their homes — a survey by Marshall & Swift/Boeckh found that 60% of homes are undervalued with regard to insurance, with an average undervaluation of 17%.

Homeowners insurance claims: cost and frequency

The average payment per homeowners claim in the U.S. was $8,787, according to data from the Insurance Research Council. Five claims were filed and paid per 100 insured homes in the last year. Claim frequency has decreased over the last two decades, but the average amount paid per claim has increased significantly.

If you exclude catastrophes, such as hurricanes and severe storms, the average claim size remains about the same ($8,772). However, the frequency of home insurance paid claims drops to one per 29 insured homes per year, or about 3.5% of insured homes.

Trend data from Lexis Nexis shows that Colorado and Nebraska consistently have the highest loss costs out of all 50 states and the District of Columbia. From the six-year period between 2013 and 2019, these two states have had the most expensive total losses. In 2019 — the most recent year for which Lexis Nexis data is available — Colorado topped the list.

According to an analysis of Travelers Insurance policyholders, the most common causes of home insurance claims are wind, nonweather water damage, hail, weather-related water damage and theft. Altogether, these five causes make up 77% of all homeowners insurance claims.

Fire caused the most costly homeowners insurance claims, accounting for 25% of claim costs, though it wasn't one of the most common claims filed. All of the other top perils in terms of total-claims cost were incidents that made the most common claims list: hail, windstorm damage, nonweather water damage and weather-related water damage.

Cause of homeowners insurance claims: property vs. liability losses

The Insurance Services Office (ISO) found that 98.1% of homeowners insurance losses are due to property damage. Similar to the findings from Travelers, the ISO’s analysis reported that wind and hail damage accounted for 34.4% of home insurance losses.

The balance of nonproperty damage losses comes from liability cases such as personal injury, medical payments and credit card claims. Delving deeper into the numbers, we can look at what usually causes the property damage.

Property and liability claims as a percentage of total homeowners insurance losses

Theft accounted for just 1% of homeowners insurance losses. When we look at what possessions are most frequently mentioned in homeowner claims, data from Enservio shows that jewelry tops the list. Electronics and apparel are also common subjects of claims that involve damage or theft.

Cost of homeowners insurance: change over time

The average annual cost of homeowners insurance in the U.S. is $1,445, according to ValuePenguin's 2021 analysis using a sample policy in each state. The average money spent on homeowners insurance coverage has risen in the past several years, across all forms of policy, based on the NAIC's survey of premiums spent. Average money spent on homeowners insurance premiums increased 15% between 2013 and 2018.

Homeowners insurance companies: market share

While there are dozens of homeowners insurance companies in the U.S., a large portion of the market is dominated by just a few. In 2019, the five top insurers accounted for 45% of direct premiums written for homeowners multiperil policies. This pattern has been fairly consistent over the past five years — in 2014, the top five insurers held 47% of the total market share — though the set of top insurers has changed.

Perils covered by homeowners insurance

Named peril policies cover dwelling and property damage from only those situations that are listed within your policy. Named perils can typically include:

Depending on where you live and the type of policy you have, some of these perils may not be included. For instance, in states prone to hurricanes, such as Florida and Texas, you will likely have to purchase separate wind and hail insurance coverage.

All perils policies cover dwelling and property damage from all situations except those specifically excluded. Perils that are consistently excluded include:

Sources