Renters Insurance
shield logo
Find Insurers
arrow logo

.

The Best Renters Insurance Companies

Below, we list the best renters insurance companies to help you find the right policy, whether you're looking for the cheapest rates or top-rated service.

Renters insurance is a cost-effective way to protect your personal property against the threat of damage or theft. It also secures you against the costs of legal liability in certain situations. On average, a renters policy won't cost you more than $16 every month.

Compare cheap renters insurance options near you

{"onCurrent":"true","product":"renters","defaultZip":"90210","customEventLabel":"Zip code quotebox"}


You can get renters insurance from both major insurers such as State Farm and newer startups such as Lemonade, but the right fit depends on what you want out of a policy. Our recommendations highlight companies that fit a variety of preferences ranging from great customer service to quick and easy coverage.

Most affordable renters insurance rates: State Farm

With State Farm, renters get both affordable policy premiums and reliable customer support.

Insurer Details

  • A.M. Best Rating: A++ (Superior)
  • J.D. Power Rank: 2nd of 14 insurers
  • Unique Value: Best rates and nationwide availability

Read the Full Review

If cost is your main concern as a renter, State Farm's consistently cheap renters policies are a great choice. In addition, its national presence and great reviews suggest that State Farm customers also enjoy access to consistently great customer support.

State Farm also gives renters many ways to customize their coverage. In its online quote form, you can not only adjust your coverage limits but also add endorsements for specific high-value belongings. The form also runs you through a few questions that are used to identify any State Farm discounts you qualify for.

Best customer service: American Family

AmFam's replacement cost coverage and top-notch satisfaction ratings make it ideal for renters who want to be sure they'll get their money's worth.

Insurer Details

  • A.M. Best Rating: A (Excellent)
  • J.D. Power Rank: 1st out of 14 insurers
  • Unique Value: Industry-leading customer satisfaction

Read the Full Review

If you've ever had to go back and forth with an insurance company over a problem, you'll understand the value of an insurer like American Family. Also known as AmFam, this company came out on top of the 2019 J.D. Power rankings for overall satisfaction among renters insurance providers.

AmFam's high reputation is rooted in its user-friendly approach: It scored well in areas like the billing process, transparency of policy information and service interactions. On top of that, AmFam's standard renters policy comes with replacement cost coverage, which means you'll have enough to replace any lost or broken possessions with new items of a like kind.

Best mobile app experience: Allstate

Allstate's convenient mobile apps give renters more flexibility and control over their policies.

Insurer Details

  • A.M. Best Rating: A+ (Superior)
  • J.D. Power Rank: 5th out of 14 insurers
  • Unique Value: Mobile apps for bills, claims and documenting property

Read the Full Review

While we expected a startup to lead the way in new technology for delivering renters insurance, we found insurance giant Allstate at the head of the pack. Renters insured by Allstate have access to two key mobile apps. Allstate Mobile lets you pay bills, file claims and review coverage information, while Digital Locker offers a way to store photos of your personal possessions in the event that you ever need to make a claim.

No other insurers we've reviewed offer Allstate's level of digital convenience for renters. Uniquely, Allstate also allows you to adjust coverage limits in order to fit your needs and budget. For instance, you could opt out of off-premises theft protection, which can save about 22% on your annual premium.

Best for quick coverage: Lemonade

No renters insurance provider offers faster quotes and claims than Lemonade. Its rates are also quite low.

Insurer Details

  • Demotech Financial Stability Rating: A (Exceptional)
  • J.D. Power Rank: Not included
  • Unique Value: Adjustable coverage limits and rapid claims payouts

Read the Full Review

If you’re looking for quick renters insurance coverage, you probably won't find a company with a process smoother than Lemonade's. Downloading Lemonade's app, getting a quote and paying to start coverage takes only a matter of minutes. The company achieves this by replacing the traditional agent experience with an artificial intelligence bot named Maya.

The coverage at Lemonade is cheap, which adds to the company's value for consumers. Active users also gain the advantage of being able to adjust your coverage limits from month to month as needed. As for claims, Lemonade says that 25% of claims on its platform are paid in three seconds. This is far, far faster than most traditional claim processes.

As a newcomer to insurance, Lemonade is only available in 26 states and Washington D.C. However, the list has been expanding sporadically.

  • Arkansas
  • Arizona
  • California
  • Colorado
  • Connecticut
  • District Of Columbia
  • Georgia
  • Iowa
  • Illinois
  • Indiana
  • Massachusetts
  • Maryland
  • Michigan
  • Missouri
  • New Jersey
  • New Mexico
  • Nevada
  • New York
  • Ohio
  • Oklahoma
  • Oregon
  • Pennsylvania
  • Rhode Island
  • Tennessee
  • Texas
  • Virginia
  • Wisconsin

Best for renters in the military: USAA

If you're a veteran or on active duty, USAA's vaunted customer service and military-friendly coverages make it the best choice.

Insurer Details

  • A.M. Best Financial Strength Rating: A++ (Superior)
  • J.D. Power Rank: Score tied for 1st of 14 insurers
  • Unique value: Military-only rates and service on all products

See our full review of USAA

USAA enjoys a well-earned reputation among the U.S. military community, and its benefits extend to renters. It offers affordable renters policies that include replacement cost coverage and protection against floods, earthquakes, windstorms and lighting — perils which are almost always excluded from renters insurance at other companies.

USAA's familiarity with the unique needs of military members only adds to its value. For example, USAA’s renters insurance policies provide deductible-free coverage for lost military uniforms. And once you decide to buy a home or a new car, USAA's broad stable of financial products gives you access to the same quality of service in those areas too.

Find Cheap Renters Insurance Quotes in Your Area

Currently insured?
{"id":4,"isAgeFieldVisible":true,"isInsuranceTypeFieldVisible":true,"isInsuredStatusFieldVisible":true,"buttonText":"Find Insurers","customEventLabel":"","defaultZip":"","defaultProduct":"renters","quoteWizardEndpoint":"https:\/\/quotes.valuepenguin.com","trackingKey":"_best-renters-insurance-companies","tier":"default","title":"Find Cheap Renters Insurance Quotes in Your Area","vendor":"vp"}

Comparing the cheapest renters insurance companies

While price isn't the only factor in choosing the right insurance, it's obviously one of the most important. To give you a baseline idea of what to expect, we've compared renters insurance rates from five of the biggest insurers for 12 months of coverage. If you're determined to find the cheapest provider of renter's insurance, make sure you compare quotes for your address.

Comparison of renters insurance rates from largest property insurers

InsurerAverage annual premium
State Farm$205
Liberty Mutual$233
Nationwide$338
Farmers$343
Allstate$367
Number is an average of rates across the 10 most populous states with data availability: California, Texas, New York, Illinois, Pennsylvania, Ohio, Michigan, Georgia, North Carolina and New Jersey

State Farm offered the most affordable renters insurance among the five major insurers, with an average annual premium of $205. The country's leading property insurer had the cheapest renters insurance policy in five of the 10 states we surveyed, with Texas the only state in which it ranked worse than second.

With an average annual premium of $233, Liberty Mutual wasn't far behind State Farm. Given the minimal difference in rates, it's definitely worth getting a second quote from Liberty Mutual if you're looking for an affordable renters insurance policy.

Nationwide had an average annual premium of $338, quite a bit more than State Farm or Liberty Mutual. The only state where Nationwide had notably cheap rates compared to its competitors was Texas, where it ranked second of the five insurers.

Farmers ranked as the second priciest insurer with an average annual renters insurance premium of $343. However, quotes from Farmers showed more variation than usual: In California, Michigan and New Jersey, its rates ranked among the cheapest. This makes Farmers worth checking out just in case it's affordable for your area.

Allstate's renters insurance quotes were the most expensive in our sample, with an average annual premium of $367. Though we recommend Allstate for its excellent digital experience, the numbers suggest that you should make sure to compare its rates against other options before you commit.

Why renters should care about more than premiums

Renters insurance is meant to protect you against large expenses, like having to replace all of your personal items. This makes coverage limits a huge consideration. Cheap policies might not always be worth the savings: Renters insurance only costs an average of $187 per year, while having insufficient coverage can cost a renter thousands.

A slightly more expensive policy that offers coverage better-suited to your needs can often be worth the extra cost.

For example, one policy might be more expensive but also more attractive to a renter, because it includes a higher coverage limit for their jewelry collection. Simply put, paying a few more dollars per month might be worth it if you ever have to file a claim.

What does renters insurance cover?

All renters insurance policies include three main coverages. Choosing higher limits for these coverages will give you more protection, but will also increase your total premium.

Personal property coverage reimburses you if your personal belongings are damaged or stolen by a covered peril. This is the bedrock of any renters insurance policy. You'll want a personal property coverage limit of at least the total value of your belongings. The average two-room rental holds possessions totaling $30,000 in value.

Personal liability coverage covers the legal costs of being found liable for property damage or bodily injury. A standard renters insurance policy covers you for up to $100,000 in legal liability coverage, but coverage levels of up to $500,000 usually cost just a few extra dollars per month.

In our view, the standard $100,000 coverage limit is generally sufficient, but there's no guarantee it will be enough. If someone sustains a significant injury at or near your unit and it's determined that the injury is due to your negligence, you could be on the hook for far more.

Additional living expenses (ALE) coverage, also called loss of use coverage, funds expenses that occur when you're forced to leave your home due to a fire or other covered event. ALE covers your costs of living elsewhere — such as a hotel — up to policy limits. Loss of use coverage limits are usually set as a percentage of your personal property coverage limit.

Beyond these standard features, many renters insurance policies have optional coverage features that can guard you against other unexpected and costly events. These may include:

  • Water backup coverage
  • Identity theft coverage
  • Coverage for earthquakes and sinkholes

If you live in an area more vulnerable to particular disasters, or if you're concerned about less common risks such as identity theft, paying extra for these additional coverages can make sense.

How to save on renters insurance

Carriers provide a number of ways for you to save on your renters insurance premium. Raising your deductible will lower your monthly bill but costs you more in a claim situation. On the other hand, qualifying for policy discounts often helps reduce your costs with no downsides.

Renters insurance deductibles

A deductible is the amount of money you must pay when you file an insurance claim. Higher deductibles mean less protection and lower costs, while lower deductibles lead to more protection and higher rates.

Example

You file a claim for $6,000 in property damage due to vandalism, and your policy has a $500 deductible. Your insurer will send you a check for $5,500: the value of the claim minus the value of the deductible.

If you had chosen a higher deductible — say $1,000 — the amount on your check would have been only $5,000. Ultimately, choosing a deductible comes down to your preference for risk: You either save money on your premium or save money on any potential claims.

Renters insurance discounts

Many insurers provide discounts for those customers who take safety precautions in their homes, or for those who buy multiple insurance policies.

Example

Tenants who have installed safety devices in their apartment or home, such as smoke and burglary alarms, are considered lower-risk policyholders, and will often receive discounts on their policies.

When you shop for renters insurance, consider whether you have any devices that could qualify you for discounts. If you're shopping for multiple policies, buying them all from the same provider may save you money on all of them. However, you should still compare prices across insurers: There is no guarantee that bundled policies with a single insurer will be cheaper than individual insurance policies from separate insurers.

How we chose the best renters insurance companies

While there might not be one renters insurance company that fits everyone's needs, evaluating what’s most important to you can help you narrow down your decision and select a company that makes the most sense.

Renters Insurance CompanyBest for…
State FarmCheap rates
ErieHigh ratings and reviews
AllstateTechnology-savvy policyholders
LemonadeQuick coverage
USAAU.S. military and their families

We compared renters insurance companies across three primary categories: rates, reviews and ratings, and financial strength.

  • Rates: Since renters insurance varies widely depending on a multitude of factors, namely your place of residence, we searched for companies that consistently offered low rates. Regardless, you’ll want to compare your renters insurance rates to national and state averages to ensure that you’re receiving competitive rates.
  • Reviews and ratings: How a company is reviewed and rated is very telling of its claims process. You’ll want an insurance company with great reviews and ratings so that if you ever need to file a claim, you’ll have peace of mind knowing that your company has a strong track record of on-time payments.
  • Financial strength: Your renters insurance policy is only as good as your insurance company’s ability to meet your claims. A company with a great financial strength rating is unlikely to have trouble meeting any claims payment.
Chris Moon

Chris is a Product Manager for ValuePenguin with years of experience in addressing critical questions about mortgages and homeowners insurance. He spends his time evaluating insurance providers and policy features to understand where consumers might find the most cost-effective coverage. Chris has contributed insights to the New York Times and many other publications.

Editorial Note: The content of this article is based on the author’s opinions and recommendations alone. It has not been previewed, commissioned or otherwise endorsed by any of our network partners.