The Best and Cheapest Home Insurance Companies in New York for 2026
Find Cheap Home Insurance Quotes in New York
Best cheap home insurance in New York
The cheapest homeowners insurance companies in New York
NYCM has the best home insurance rates in New York, regardless of how much coverage you need.
Find Cheap Home Insurance Quotes in New York
-
A policy from NYCM costs an average of $588 per year for $350,000 of
dwelling coverage.
That makes it 58% cheaper than the state average.
NYCM also has the lowest rates if you have a more expensive house. An NYCM home policy for $1 million of coverage costs $1,631 per year, 58% below the state average.
-
If you have complicated home insurance needs or want the stability of buying coverage from a major national company, consider Nationwide. Its coverage options and service are both excellent, and its prices are cheaper than average.
Cheap annual home insurance quotes in New York
$200,000
$350,000
$500,000
$1 million
Key takeaways
- New York home insurance rates went up around 4.3% in 2025, less than the jump nationally of 5.6%. New York home insurance prices have had relatively small increases over the last five years. Rates have increased about half as fast in the Empire State as in the country overall. This may be because major contributors to increasing home insurance costs, like severe hurricanes and wildfires, have not impacted New York much.
- USAA, Travelers and State Farm raised rates the least among major New York insurance companies during the past five years. USAA has only raised NY rates once since 2021, by only 6.7%. Travelers customers pay 14.3% more now than in 2021, and State Farm customers pay 18.0% more.
- New York homeowners may be able to save on home insurance by looking for a local insurer. The three cheapest companies overall, NYCM Insurance, Preferred Mutual and Sterling Insurance, are all smaller regional companies with lower rates.
Best for most people: NYCM
Pros & cons
- Cheapest rates in New York
- Many discounts available
- Good customer service
- No online quotes
- Few coverage options
Why is NYCM the best?
NYCM has the lowest rates in the state. $350,000 of coverage to repair or rebuild your home, called dwelling coverage, costs an average of $588 per year. That's $799 per year less expensive than the average home insurance cost in New York. Its rates are about 60% cheaper than average.
How much is NYCM Insurance in New York?
NYCM also has the cheapest rates for more expensive homes in New York. An NYCM homeowners policy with $500,000 of dwelling coverage costs an average of $782 per year, and a policy with $1 million of dwelling coverage with NYCM costs $1,631 per year. Those are both around 60% cheaper than average statewide.
NYCM gets about one-third fewer complaints than expected for an insurance company its size, according to the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC). That means you're more likely to be happy with the service you receive.
The company also offers a wide selection of discounts, which could bring your rates down further. It offers bundle and claim-free discounts, as well as less common discount options, including for retirees, people who work from home and green-certified buildings.
Potential issues
NYCM's biggest shortcoming is its small list of extra coverages. If you're looking for specialized coverage options like water backup, flood coverage or guaranteed replacement cost, you'll need to look elsewhere.
Also, unlike many major home insurance companies, NYCM doesn't offer online quotes. That means you'll have to pick up the phone and speak to a local agent to get a quote.
Best coverage options: Nationwide
Pros & cons
- Lots of useful coverage options
- Excellent customer service
- Not the cheapest rates
Why is Nationwide the best?
Nationwide has an excellent range of extra coverage options, making it a great choice for homeowners who need more than the basics. For example, coastal Long Island homeowners may want extra protection from water damage, while those living upstate may benefit from more hail protection. Nationwide offers flood insurance, as well as a special "roof upgrade" coverage that can help you build an even stronger roof after it's damaged.
Nationwide homeowners extra coverage options
- Extended dwelling replacement cost covers repair costs up to double your coverage limits if prices jump after a major disaster. Better roof replacement will help you build your roof back even stronger if it's damaged. Building ordinance or law will pay for upgrades to your home required by law after a covered loss. Water backup coverage will pay for water damage caused by a backed-up drain or sewer. Valuables Plus coverage will pay to replace or repair expensive personal property such as a necklace or painting. Identity theft coverage protects against identity theft.
In addition, Nationwide sells separate flood, earthquake and personal liability umbrella policies.
Nationwide's customer service is also extremely reliable. It received an above-average rating in J.D. Power's claims satisfaction survey. It also received only one quarter as many complaints as a typical insurance company, suggesting Nationwide customers are usually happy with the service they receive.
Potential issues
While Nationwide's prices are slightly cheaper than average in New York, the company is much more expensive than NYCM. For a policy with $350,000 of dwelling coverage, Nationwide's average price of $1,270 per year is more than double the typical rate at NYCM.
Additionally, Nationwide's performance in J.D. Power's overall customer satisfaction survey was worse than for claims, which suggests the experience of buying a policy from Nationwide could be slightly worse than average.
Best for high-value homes: Chubb
Pros & cons
- Very strong claims service
- Coverages tailored for high-value properties
- Very expensive
- Not available for cheaper homes
Why is Chubb the best?
For people with high-value homes (at least $500,000 rebuild cost), Chubb is renowned for its claims service and generous coverage options.
Chubb is a great choice if you want ultimate peace-of-mind and you're willing to pay for it.
Chubb received the best rating of any home insurance company in J.D. Power's claims satisfaction survey, and it has 90% fewer complaints than an average company its size, according to the NAIC. Customers are overwhelmingly satisfied with the service they receive from Chubb, especially when it comes to making a claim.
The company also has lots of coverage options tailored to people with a high net worth. For example, it offers a "cash-out" option: If your home is destroyed, such as in a fire, you can simply choose to receive a cash payout of the amount Chubb owes you. Nearly all insurance companies require you to use your payout to rebuild your home. But if you own multiple homes, a cash payout would allow you to simply sell the land and move on from the destroyed property.
All Chubb home insurance policies include replacement cost coverage for both the structure of your home and your property, and Chubb has a reputation for generous claim payouts. That means you won't have to worry about getting enough money to fully fund a repair or replacement after you file a claim.
Potential issues
Chubb home insurance is very expensive, and it's only available for high-value homes.
The company doesn't share the exact minimum home value you need to buy a policy, but in general, homes that cost less than $500,000 to rebuild can't be covered by a Chubb policy. Depending on where you live, the minimum coverage amount could be even higher.
Even if you are eligible for coverage, you'll likely pay a lot for it. Chubb is about 50% more expensive than a typical New York insurance company for both $500,000 and $1 million policies.
What are the top-rated homeowners insurance companies in New York?
Nationwide and Chubb have the best-rated customer service for New York homeowners.
These two companies fared well in J.D. Power's latest customer satisfaction surveys, and they have very few complaints from the NAIC. Chubb has the best rating overall, but it's only available to people with very expensive homes.
How much does home insurance cost in New York?
Homeowners insurance in New York costs 42% less than the national average.
The Northeast has cheaper homeowners rates compared to the U.S. as a whole. That's likely because this region gets few natural disasters.
You'll pay about the same for homeowners insurance in New York as you would in neighboring states like New Jersey.
Cost of homeowners insurance in New York by city
The most expensive city for home insurance in New York is Napeague, on the South Fork of Long Island.
The average price in Napeague is $3,257 per year for $350,000 of dwelling coverage. That's about 135% more than the state average.
Home insurance in New York tends to be most expensive in outer Long Island, as that area is more susceptible to coastal storms. Homes there may also be harder to repair or rebuild, given the area's relatively isolated location.
Who has the cheapest home insurance in NYC?
NYCM has the lowest home insurance rates in NYC, at $1,012 per year for $500,000 of dwelling coverage, or 67% cheaper than average.
Staten Island has the cheapest home insurance in NYC, while Manhattan has the most expensive.
Standard home insurance policies in New York only apply to single-family homes, whether they're freestanding or share a wall with their neighbor. If you live in a condo or co-op apartment building, you'll need a different kind of home insurance.
Annual home insurance rates in NY by city
What natural disasters should I watch out for in New York?
New York's most common natural disasters are heavy rainstorms, as well as coastal storms like nor'easters and occasional hurricanes.
Home insurance generally covers damage from wind and hail, but if your home is at risk of flooding, you'll likely need a separate policy.
Is wind damage covered by home insurance in New York?
Homeowners insurance almost always covers wind damage.
As a coastal state on the Eastern Seaboard, New York is vulnerable to nor'easters, tropical storms and other large storms that can cause damage to your home. This is especially true if you live on Long Island, in New York City or in the Lower Hudson Valley.
New
Are snow and hail damage covered by home insurance in New York?
If your roof or other parts of your home are damaged by hail or the weight of snow, you'll usually be covered by home insurance.
Hail damage was the single biggest cause of property damage from natural disasters in New York in 2025, accounting for $20 million of damage to roofs, cars and other property, according to the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA).
Snow was another serious cause of damage, causing more than $2 million in damage in 2025.
However, you may not be covered for all types of damage. Home insurance policies won't cover hail or snow damage to your car, and may exclude damage to landscaping or trees.
Is flooding covered by home insurance in New York?
Your home insurance policy won't cover flood damage. If you live in a coastal zone or an area with a high risk of flooding, you'll need to buy a separate flood insurance policy.
This is particularly important for people living in low-lying areas, near major rivers or along the coast. The National Flood Insurance Program has paid out more than $300 million in claims in New York between 2015 and 2025, with more than half of the total claim value paid out to people in Westchester and Long Island.
Tips for buying the best home insurance in New York
New York home insurance trends
Home insurance prices are up 24.4% in New York over the last five years.
New York homeowners have seen mild increases in their home insurance prices in recent years, with an average increase of 5.2% in 2024, followed by a 4.3% increase in 2025.
New York's rate increases have been lower than the country overall. Nationally, home insurance prices have jumped 47.9% since 2021, and 5.6% in 2025.
Home insurance rate hikes in New York, 2021-2025
Heritage Insurance saw the biggest increase among larger NY companies, with a jump of 68.3% over the last five years.
USAA, Travelers and State Farm customers experienced the smallest rate increases, at just 6.7%, 14.3% and 18.0%, respectively.
Home insurance rate change data was compiled using RateWatch from S&P Global, which uses information from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC).
Frequently asked questions
How much is homeowners insurance in New York?
The average cost of home insurance in New York is $1,387 per year, or $116 per month for $350,000 of dwelling coverage.
Who has the cheapest homeowners insurance in New York?
NYCM, New York Central Mutual Insurance Co., offers the best home insurance rates in the state. A typical policy costs $588 per year, which is 58% cheaper than the statewide average.
Methodology
To find the best homeowners insurance in New York, ValuePenguin gathered quotes in every ZIP code in the state from the largest homeowners insurance companies. Rates are for a 1,490 square foot home built 52 years ago, based on the average home age and size in New York.
ValuePenguin sourced quotes for properties at four levels of dwelling coverage to understand the cost of coverage for a variety of homes.
- Dwelling coverage: $200,000, $350,000, $500,000 or $1 million
- Personal liability: $100,000
- Medical payments: $1,000
- Deductible: $1,000
ValuePenguin's analysis used insurance rate data from Quadrant Information Services. These rates were publicly sourced from insurer filings and should be used for comparative purposes only — your own quotes will be different.
Each company's customer service was ranked by comparing the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) complaint index, J.D. Power's home insurance customer satisfaction and claims satisfaction rankings, and ValuePenguin editor's ratings.
Cost information for disasters was gathered from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) and the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP).
About the Author
Lead Writer
Matt Timmons is a Lead Writer on the insurance team at ValuePenguin, where he writes in-depth and timely pieces helping find the right coverage for them.
He's covered insurance at ValuePenguin since 2018, specializing in auto and home insurance, as well as life insurance. He's paid special attention to the EV insurance market, where prices are much higher than for gas cars.
Before he started writing about personal finance, Matt wrote about professional skills and online tools at an e-learning company.
How insurance helped Matt
During freshman orientation in college, Matt's iPod was stolen off his table while he was eating lunch. Luckily, he'd bought a college insurance plan the day before and he had money to buy a replacement before classes started.
Expertise
- Auto insurance
- Home insurance
- Insurance rate analysis
- Life insurance
Referenced by
- CNBC
- Miami Herald
- Yahoo! Finance
Education
- BA, Wesleyan University
Editorial Note: The content of this article is based on the author's opinions and recommendations alone. It has not been previewed, commissioned or otherwise endorsed by any of our network partners.
