Who Has the Cheapest Auto Insurance Quotes in Illinois? (2019)

Find the Cheapest Auto Insurance Quotes in Your Area

Currently insured?
{"id":8,"isAgeFieldVisible":true,"isInsuranceTypeFieldVisible":true,"isInsuredStatusFieldVisible":true,"customEventLabel":"","defaultZip":"","defaultProduct":"auto","quoteWizardEndpoint":"https:\/\/quotes.valuepenguin.com","trackingKey":"_best-cheap-car-insurance-illinois","title":"Find the Cheapest Auto Insurance Quotes in Your Area","vendor":"vp"}

We analyzed auto insurance rates in the state of Illinois to give readers an indication of which companies were the cheapest for local drivers. Though the average annual vehicle insurance cost in Illinois was $1,158, you can pay significantly more or less for your insurance policy depending on which company you decide to use. For example, Victoria—the most expensive insurer in the state, among those we surveyed—had annual car insurance premiums 175% greater than the company with the cheapest rates, Auto Owners.

Additionally, the auto insurance company with the lowest rates for you can change from year-to-year—some insurers have raised rates by as much as 29% since 2017. As such, we always tell our readers to shop around and get quotes from multiple companies to get great rates. If you want to find out which auto insurers operate in your area, enter your zip code in the box above.

Cheapest Auto Insurance in Illinois

As part of our comparison study, we looked at quotes from 28 different companies across multiple cities in the state to identify which had the cheapest rates in Illinois for car insurance. We calculated the average quote at each company based on our benchmark driver, a single 30-year-old man, and ranked them from the cheapest insurers to the most expensive:

In this graph we rank the car insurance companies in Illinois from the cheapest to the most expensive

Find the Cheapest Auto Insurance Quotes in Your Area

Currently insured?
{"id":7,"isAgeFieldVisible":true,"isInsuranceTypeFieldVisible":false,"isInsuredStatusFieldVisible":true,"customEventLabel":"","defaultZip":"","defaultProduct":"auto","quoteWizardEndpoint":"https:\/\/quotes.valuepenguin.com","trackingKey":"_best-cheap-car-insurance-illinois","title":"Find the Cheapest Auto Insurance Quotes in Your Area","vendor":"vp"}

Our quote analysis found that Unique Insurance was the cheapest auto insurance company in Illinois for our sample driver, on average. Close behind Unique were Farmers, Lighthouse, Rockford Mutual, and The Hartford, which rounded out the top five most affordable companies for car insurance in the Prairie State. Unique's rates were 45% cheaper than the state average for our sample motorists—in fact, a year at the costliest company could pay for over 3 years of coverage at Unique. Here are the rest of the companies we surveyed:

RankAuto Insurance CompanyAverage Annual Rates
1Unique$641
2Farmers$645
3Lighthouse$714
4Rockford Mutual$781
5The Hartford$819
6The Cincinnati$871
7Auto Club Group$884
8State Farm$897
9SECURA$938
10Country$957
11Nationwide$962
12Erie$966
13Pekin Insurance$1,000
14Auto Owners$1,030
15X21st Century$1,074
16GEICO$1,095
17American Family$1,101
18State Auto$1,178
19American Freedom$1,242
20Progressive$1,278
21Hastings Mutual$1,410
22The General$1,458
23Mercury$1,480
24Allstate$1,496
25Grange$1,556
26Kemper Specialty$1,830
27MetLife$1,996
28Hanover$2,120

Cheapest Car Insurance in Illinois: by City

With almost 58,000 square miles of land, Illinois is the fifth most populous state and the 24th largest by land mass in the country. Prices for local auto insurance can vary depending on where people live and park their car in Illinois. The most expensive city in Illinois was Chicago. Costs in Chicago are about 1.8x costs in Normal, the cheapest city statewide. Regardless of what average costs are in each city, comparing auto insurance quotes near you will lead to cheaper rates. Below you will find a table of cities in Illinois and their most affordable insurers.

CityAuto Insurance CompanyAverage Annual Rates
Arlington HeightsUnique$552
Farmers$564
Lighthouse$588
AuroraUnique$564
Farmers$600
Lighthouse$636
BartlettLighthouse$636
Farmers$648
Rockford Mutual$660
BentonFarmers$660
Rockford Mutual$804
State Farm$816
BerwynUnique$624
Lighthouse$696
Farmers$768
BloomingtonFarmers$552
Unique$624
The Cincinnati$636
BolingbrookUnique$576
Lighthouse$660
Farmers$696
Carol StreamFarmers$540
Unique$552
Lighthouse$588
CarpentersvilleUnique$564
Lighthouse$636
Farmers$648
ChicagoUnique$720
Lighthouse$804
Farmers$816
CiceroUnique$624
Lighthouse$696
Farmers$996
Crystal LakeFarmers$528
Lighthouse$552
Unique$564
DanvilleFarmers$528
Unique$624
Rockford Mutual$708
DecaturFarmers$540
Rockford Mutual$648
Unique$648
DekalbFarmers$420
Unique$612
Rockford Mutual$672
Des PlainesUnique$600
Lighthouse$636
Farmers$756
ElginUnique$564
Lighthouse$636
Farmers$684
ElmhurstUnique$552
Lighthouse$588
Farmers$624
EvanstonUnique$624
Lighthouse$684
Farmers$768
FreeportFarmers$504
Rockford Mutual$660
Auto Club Group$708
GalesburgFarmers$636
The Cincinnati$636
Rockford Mutual$648
Hanover ParkUnique$552
Lighthouse$588
Rockford Mutual$660
Highland ParkUnique$552
Lighthouse$600
Farmers$720
Hoffman EstatesUnique$552
Lighthouse$588
Farmers$612
KewaneeFarmers$648
The Hartford$672
Unique$672
La GrangeUnique$660
Lighthouse$672
Farmers$696
LombardFarmers$540
Unique$552
Lighthouse$588
MacombFarmers$564
Unique$672
The Hartford$708
MchenryFarmers$600
Unique$612
Lighthouse$636
MolineFarmers$516
Unique$660
Lighthouse$720
MortonFarmers$468
State Farm$720
Unique$720
NapervilleUnique$552
Farmers$576
Lighthouse$588
NilesUnique$624
Lighthouse$684
Farmers$768
NormalFarmers$504
Unique$624
The Cincinnati$636
NorthbrookUnique$552
Farmers$600
Lighthouse$600
Oak LawnUnique$660
Lighthouse$672
Farmers$732
Oak ParkUnique$624
Lighthouse$696
Farmers$708
Orland ParkFarmers$660
Unique$660
Lighthouse$672
PalatineUnique$552
Lighthouse$588
Farmers$600
PanaFarmers$636
The Hartford$684
Unique$708
Park RidgeUnique$600
Farmers$636
Lighthouse$636
PlainfieldUnique$576
Farmers$612
Lighthouse$660
RiversideUnique$660
Lighthouse$672
Farmers$768
Rock IslandFarmers$612
Unique$660
Lighthouse$720
RockfordUnique$660
Lighthouse$720
Farmers$756
RomeovilleFarmers$552
Unique$576
Lighthouse$660
SchaumburgUnique$552
Lighthouse$588
Farmers$624
SkokieUnique$624
Lighthouse$684
Farmers$840
SpringfieldFarmers$612
Rockford Mutual$696
Unique$708
StreamwoodUnique$564
Farmers$636
Lighthouse$636
Tinley ParkFarmers$624
Unique$660
Lighthouse$672
WaukeganUnique$516
Lighthouse$564
Farmers$648
WheatonFarmers$540
Unique$552
Lighthouse$588
WheelingUnique$552
Lighthouse$588
Rockford Mutual$684

Chicago, IL

The largest city in Illinois and third largest in the United States, nearly three million people call Chicago home.. Auto insurance costs in the Windy City were found to be $1,765 per year for a state minimum policy, which works out to be 52% more expensive than our average.

If you're looking for cheap car insurance in Chicago, we suggest starting with Unique, Lighthouse, and Farmers. The average premium quoted at the three cheapest companies in Chicago was $780 for a minimum policy, which could mean about 56% more savings compared to the typical insurer here. It certainly pays to compare rates before choosing an insurer.

This graph shows the five carriers in Chicago with the lowest rates for auto insurance.

Aurora, IL

Illinois's second largest city, Aurora is a suburban town 40 miles west of downtown Chicago with 200,000 residents inside the city limits. As one of the first U.S. cities to have electric street lights throughout town, Aurora is nicknamed the "City of Lights" and is so large it extends into four different Illinois counties. As the second most populous city in the state, Aurora fared much better than Chicago in regards to auto insurance rates. Our sample drivers pays $1,108 annually.

For low-cost vehicle insurance quotes near you in Aurora, we recommend that you include Unique, Farmers, Lighthouse, Auto Club Group, and The Hartford in your list of companies to review. We found that these five insurers quoted our sample drivers in Aurora similarly cheap rates, with a mean quote of $665 per year—40% less than what the typical Aurora motorist pays. Especially in the case of Unique, our local motorist (a single 30-year-old man) found quotes as cheap as $564 a year. Note that these rates are for full coverage.

This graph displays the carriers who had the lowest auto insurance quotes for our four drivers living in Aurora.

Rockford, IL

Located in north-central Illinois with the beautiful Rock River running right through its downtown, Rockford, IL is the third-most populated city in IL. Rockford has 147,051 citizens in the city, and more than double that if you include the entire metro area. Amongst other redeeming attributes of "Forest City" are its easy access to transportation, Illinois's biggest musical festival and the affordable cost of living. Annual rates in Rockford on average are $1,122 or around $94 per month for our profiled motorist.

We found the best auto insurance quotes in Rockford at Unique, Lighthouse, and Farmers. Also not far behind were The Hartford and Auto Club Group. Rates from all five companies averaged $744 a year – that's 34% less than the average going cost of $1,122 in Rockford. Whether you are married or single, we recommend including these local companies into your insurer shopping list.

As this graph shows, we found the best quotes for insuring a car in Rockford at Hastings Mutual, The Hartford, SECURA, COUNTRY Financial, and Farmers.

Joliet, IL

Illinois's fastest-growing city and also its fourth largest, Joliet lies 45 minutes by car to the southwest of Chicago, along the Des Plaines River. Formerly an industrial center, Joliet has seen significant growth in recent years from entertainment and cultural industries. Our four drivers found rates averaging $1,243 per year for car insurance just meeting the state's minimum requirements—almost on par with the statewide average of $1,158.

In our analysis, however, savings could be found at these three companies, which had some of the lowest rates in Joliet: Unique, Lighthouse, and Farmers. Their average annual premium quote of $684 represents a 45% decrease versus the overall city. If you will like to add to some variety, also consider looking into Nationwide and Auto Club Group when you shop. Together, these five carriers had the most affordable auto insurance rates in Joliet for our profiled driver.

This graph shows which companies had the cheapest auto insurance quotes for our four sample driver types in Joliet, IL.

Naperville, IL

With the most affordable auto insurance of Illinois's largest cities, Naperville is a suburb of Chicago and home to 143,000+ residents. Although once a farming town, Naperville has transformed into an affluent city that has been on innumerable "Best Places to Live" lists throughout the years, and for good reason. Amongst Naperville's other accolades is the "Best Public Library" distinction. And although the cost of living is almost 20% higher in Naperville than in the rest of Illinois, its car insurance rates are cheaper than average at $1,012 per year or $84 monthly for full coverage for our sample motorist.

Unique and Farmers take the cake with the cheapest auto insurance rates for Naperville locals with premiums running around $560 per year—45% cheaper than the Naperville average. Not far behind are Lighthouse, Pekin Insurance, and Rockford Mutual, all of which represent at least $316 savings compared to what the typical Naperville insurers are charging.

This chart identifies and quantifies the rates for the insurers with the cheapest car insurance in Naperville.

Best-Rated Auto Insurers in Illinois

Trying to judge which auto insurance company is the most reliable and has the best customer service can be difficult. One statistic we think is useful is called the 'complaint ratio'. This figure captures the number of complaints each company receives in a calendar year per $1 million in written premiums. Looking for the company near you with the lowest complaint ratio can give you an apples-to-apples comparison in your search for the best auto insurance company.

Below is a list of Illinois insurers' complaint ratios, as calculated and published by the Illinois Department of Insurance based on the customer complaints reported—the latest year for which data is available. The lower the ratio, the better the company's rating.

RankCompanyComplaint Ratio
1Country Financial0.06
2Hanover0.10
3SafeCo0.12
4State Farm0.13
5Farmers0.13
6Standard Fire Insurance0.14
7Allstate0.18
8MetLife0.18
9USAA0.19
10Progressive0.21
11Erie0.21
12American Family0.22
13GEICO0.23
14Standard Mutual0.24
15Hartford0.26
16AAA0.29
17Esurance0.29
18Liberty Mutual0.32
19Allied0.34
20Auto Owners0.35
21Nationwide0.40
22Bristol West Insurance Company0.49
23Safe Auto Insurance Company0.52
24Ameriprise0.58
25Mendota Insurance0.68
26Elephant Insurance Company1.17
27First Acceptance Insurance Company Inc.1.46
28Safeway Insurance Company1.48
29American Access Casualty Company1.60
30Fred Loya Insurance1.63
31First Chicago Insurance Company1.75
32Unique Insurance Company3.18
33Founders Insurance Company3.28
34Falcon Insurance Company3.36
35Stonegate Insurance Company3.76
36American Freedom Insurance Company4.24
37American Alliance Casualty Company4.30
38Lighthouse Casualty Company4.95
39Direct Auto Insurance Company5.85
40United Equitable Insurance Company6.34

Illinois Car Insurance Rate Increases

Illinois drivers have experience relatively minor rate changes in recent years, with a cumulative increase of 3% from 2017 to 2019 across the 10 largest insurers. However, it's not all good news as some insurers logged massive rate increases. American Family, for example saw a 29% premium hike during this time frame.

Insurer

Market ShareRate Change % 2017Rate Change % 2018Rate Change % 2019*Cumulative Rate Change % 2017-2019
State Farm32%0%-3%-2%-4%
Allstate12%4%0%0%5%
Country Insurance7%2%2%5%9%
GEICO6%6%4%0%10%
Progressive6%-4%-1%0%-5%
Farmers4%10%6%0%16%
American Family4%7%10%9%29%
Liberty Mutual3%6%4%0%10%
USAA2%5%6%1%12%
Travelers2%8%5%0%13%
Top 10 Groups78%2%1%0%3%

* Includes rates filings through 4/1/2019

Average Cost of Car Insurance in Illinois: by City

If you'd like to see the average price of auto insurance in your city, here is a comprehensive list of the towns we looked at. They are listed in alphabetical order.

This graph shows how much it cost our sample driver to insure a Toyota Camry across cities in Illinois

Illinois Auto Insurance Coverage Requirements

Drivers in Illinois need to abide by the state's mandatory minimum auto insurance requirements. Illinois is not a "no-fault" state and so drivers are only required to carry liability insurance. The following are the mandatory limits:

  • Bodily injury liability insurance: $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident
  • Property damage liability insurance: $20,000 per accident
  • Uninsured motorist bodily injury coverage: $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident

Study Methodology

The sample quotes we obtained were for full coverage to insure a 2011 Toyota Camry that is used for commute daily, averaging 12,000 miles a year. Our sample driver is a 30 year old single male with good credit and a clean driving history.

Finally, we looked at quotes from 28 auto insurance companies licensed that do business in Illinois, and averaged the sample vehicle insurance rates to come up with a city average. The companies we included represented a sample of the largest insurers in the state, as well as some more local companies, including but not limited to: State Farm, Allstate, Farmers, COUNTRY Financial, Cincinnati Insurance, Grange Mutual and 21st Century.

Surveyed auto insurance costs in Illinois are for illustrative purposes only and actual quotes will vary based on your physical residence, driving history, and other factors.

The state of Illinois requires financial responsibility and ability to pay for injury, death, and damage on the road. Their minimum auto insurance liability requirements, along with the limits we used in our analysis, are listed below.

CoverageState Minimum LimitsAnalysis Limits
Bodily Injury$25,000 per person / $50,000 per accident$25,000 per person / $50,000 per accident
Property Damage$20,000$25,000
Uninsured Motorist Bodily Injury$20,000 per person / $40,000 per accident$25,000 per person / $50,000 per accident
Uninsured Motorist Property DamageOptional$25,000
Collision / Comprehensive DeductibleOptional$500

Comments and Questions

Editorial Note: The content of this article is based on the author’s opinions and recommendations alone. It has not been previewed, commissioned or otherwise endorsed by any of our network partners.