Best and Cheapest Home Insurance Companies in Oklahoma

Best cheap home insurance in Oklahoma

To help Oklahoma homeowners get the best possible deal on insurance, our editorial team collected thousands of quotes and studied customer satisfaction ratings to help you compare the best companies across the state.

Cheapest home insurance in Oklahoma

Farm Bureau offers the cheapest average rate for home insurance in Oklahoma at $1,452 per year.

Home insurance in Oklahoma can be a bit pricey because of the state's severe weather patterns. The national average for home insurance is $1,516 per year, which is $762 cheaper than the Oklahoma average. In 2021, the state saw 63 recorded tornadoes that caused damage to Oklahoma homes and properties.

Cheap annual home insurance in Oklahoma

Best Oklahoma home insurance overall: Farm Bureau

Farm Bureau is the best option for most homeowners in Oklahoma. The company offers the cheapest rate for standard home insurance at $1,452 per year, or $121 per month. This is much lower than the statewide annual average rate of $2,278 per year.

Home insurance discounts include savings for bundling policies, installing burglar or fire alarms in your home and having an impact-resistant roof.

You'll need to become a Farm Bureau member to get insurance, but you'll enjoy other benefits with your membership as well. Membership discounts help you save on:

The company also boasts a 0.55 rating in the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) customer complaint index. This means the company gets 45% fewer complaints than a typical insurer of its size.

The most notable downside to Farm Bureau is the membership requirement. The membership has an annual fee, which can be anywhere from $20 to $120 depending on where you live. You’ll have to call a local Farm Bureau agent near you to sign up.

Best local home insurance: American Farmers & Ranchers

American Farmers & Ranchers (AFR) is the best local home insurance company for homeowners in Oklahoma, offering standard home insurance at a low rate of $1,864 per year, which is $414 cheaper than the statewide annual average.

The company has been serving the state of Oklahoma for over 100 years and offers 24/7 assistance for members through its "Fast and Fair Claim Service." There are also over 160 independent agents throughout the state, making access to an agent convenient and easy.

American Farmers & Ranchers holds the best customer satisfaction score among all insurance companies in Oklahoma, meaning the company gets virtually no complaints, which means most customers are satisfied with their experience.

The largest downside to the company is that you must be a member of your local AFR chapter in order to enroll in an insurance policy. However, annual fees are fairly cheap, with an average of only $35 per year.

The company also doesn’t offer many discounts, only standard savings like a multipolicy discount when you bundle home and auto insurance policies, and a claims-free discount when you have not claimed a loss within a certain period of time.

Best home insurance for severe storm coverage: Shelter

Shelter is the best home insurance company for severe storm coverage in Oklahoma. Standard home insurance policies cost $1,566 per year, or $131 per month. That's 31% cheaper than the state average rate.

Oklahoma faces a wide range of risks including tornadoes, wildfires and hailstorms in the summer. Shelter offers coverage that's especially helpful for inclement weather claims, like paid debris removal and fire department charge reimbursement.

Shelter also boasts an outstanding customer service score of 0.25 in the NAIC complaint index. This means that the company gets 75% fewer complaints than the average company its size.

The most prominent drawback to Shelter is that the company doesn’t offer many unique discounts. You can still save by bundling multiple policies, buying a new home and installing protective fire or security alarms, but Shelter offers fewer discounts than other companies.

Best home insurance for service members in Oklahoma: USAA

Oklahoma is home to Fort Sill, one of the country’s most prominent army installations. Finding the best home insurance for service members and their families is important to many Oklahoma residents.

USAA offers coverage benefits that make it especially appealing to active-duty service members, such as a deductible waiver for all issued gear that is lost, stolen or destroyed. The company also covers personal property worldwide, even in active war zones. War zones are typically excluded in most home insurance policies.

The company scored a 0.50 in the NAIC’s customer complaint index, meaning it gets half as many complaints as other typical insurers.

However, USAA offers standard home insurance at an average rate of $2,758 per year, or $230 per month. This is $480 per year more expensive than the statewide average. You also must be a service member, dependent of a service member or dependent of a USAA customer to be eligible for coverage.

Oklahoma home insurance rates by city

The cheapest city for home insurance in Oklahoma is Roland at $1,823 per year. This is $455 cheaper than the state average. Roland sits at the eastern border as part of the Fort Smith, Arkansas-Oklahoma metropolitan area.

Wheatland is the most expensive city for home insurance in Oklahoma, with an annual average rate of $2,745, or $229 per month. This is $467 more than the statewide average rate. Wheatland is a neighborhood in southwestern Oklahoma City, just west of Will Rogers World Airport.

Best home insurance companies in Oklahoma

Farm Bureau and Shelter are the best insurance companies for most homeowners in Oklahoma. Both companies offer an excellent combination of customer satisfaction and cheap rates. Farm Bureau offers the widest range of discounts, while Shelter offers the best coverage add-ons to keep homeowners protected.

USAA and American Farmers & Ranchers are also great for homeowners in Oklahoma but are only recommended for some people. USAA is only available to U.S. service members and their dependents, or dependents of current USAA customers. American Farmers & Ranchers is available for everyone but is recommended for farm or ranch owners. Both companies boast top-tier customer service.

Most common homeowners insurance risks in Oklahoma

Oklahoma experiences a higher number of major storms than most other states. The state has experienced 210 major disasters since 1953, making it the third most disaster-prone state in the country. These disasters include major thunderstorms, tornadoes, wildfires and more.

Is wind damage covered by home insurance?

Thunderstorms in Oklahoma can produce damaging winds and tornadoes. Though your homeowners insurance covers wind damage, your policy might not be enough to rebuild your home if it were destroyed. You should consider upgrading your standard homeowners insurance to include replacement cost coverage, which doesn't account for your property's depreciation after a claim.

Is hail damage covered by home insurance?

Oklahoma's thunderstorms can also produce large hail. Homeowners insurance typically covers hail, but since the state experiences hailstorms, it could be beneficial to take precautions by reinforcing your roof and windows. Most home insurance companies also offer discounts for installing impact windows.

You could also face winter storms that produce freezing rain during Oklahoma's wintertime. Your homeowners insurance likely has restrictions on freezing. For example, homeowners insurance policies don't always cover freezing that happens to plumbing systems. It’s best to check with your policy to see what it covers.

Frequently asked questions

Methodology

For our study, we gathered quotes from every ZIP code in Oklahoma. We used a sample property that was built in 1978 and insured at $136,800 of dwelling coverage, based on the U.S. Census Bureau's data on the median Oklahoma home.

ValuePenguin's analysis used insurance rate data from Quadrant Information Services. These rates were publicly sourced from insurer filings and should be used for comparative purposes only — your own quotes may be different.

We ranked each company's customer service scores by comparing the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) complaint index, J.D. Power's home insurance customer satisfaction rankings and our ValuePenguin editor's ratings.